I’ve always used snap traps and peanut butter, dating all the way back to 1968 in Vietnam. It works, and the mouse has minimal suffering.
I worked in a hospital kitchen in college and they put out glue traps. It was my job to check them daily and dispose of dead mice. One day I got to work and this little mouse had dragged himself across the glue, as they’re was a line of fur from one end of the trap to where he lay panting on the other side. My buddy and I had to decide what to do with this not-dead mouse and neither of us had the stomach to smash it to death. We took it outside with some tongs and attempted to pull it off. Our efforts ended up killing it, most likely due to shock or a heart attack.
I used to use a live-capture cage trap, back when I had vermin. I’d catch a rat or mouse, then drop the cage in a bucket of water. It’s the most efficient and most humane way, IMHO, if you have the stones for it.
Alive???
The one time that snap traps didn’t work for me, it turned out to be a rat. I had to get a bigger trap.
My brother caught a mouse in a sticky trap once and decided the humane way to end its suffering was to shoot it. (My brother had had a couple of beers.) He brought it out into his backyard and then, for reasons which he admits made no sense, he took several steps back. He aimed and fires a shot at the mouse.
At the mouse. But not into the mouse. The mouse was quite upset. My brother checked it and found that he had managed to wound the mouse but not kill it. With a gun.
So he stepped back and fired another shot.
He wounded it again.
My brother belatedly figured out that the range was the problem. (Although shooting a mouse twice and not killing might actually be kind of impressive if you had done it intentionally.) For his third shot, he held the gun next the mouse and administered the coup de grace.
As noted, one was alive and one was dead when they went into the can.
I once found a mouse wriggling in a snap trap. I broke its neck by grabbing its head in one hand and tail in the other and pulling. It stopped the wriggling and I hope it lost consciousness. This was a technique I had learned while working in a lab as a student.
Being drowned alive & conscious is NOT a pleasant way to die.
That’s sad. But in my experience, it’s a rare failure mode. I’ve killed a lot of mice in snap traps.
That is a horrid and cruel way to die.
Which one?
Well, the sticky traps in general, but being tossed alive into the trash is pretty nasty.
I caught two mice in sticky traps. I heard one while it was still alive and threw it into a garbage can. I found the other one after it had died and threw it into a garbage can. So one died in a garbage can and one died on my kitchen floor. I don’t see one place as being any worse than the other.
You know at-large(not pets) rats and mice are dirty. Maybe disease ridden. Even if that’s not an issue. My house is made of logs. I’d prefer things that don’t chew on it to inhabit it.
I can’t really gin up much sympathy for them.
Sorry.
Tho’ I’m agreeing exhaustion killed the glue trap mouse in the OP.
And maybe what kills the snap trap mice. Unless you see it instantly die how can you know how long it lived after the trap snapped in to it.
Worse than having their back snapped, or suffering a heart attack after being glued to a surface? Death is never pleasant; drowning, at least, is quick.
I have had to terminate a mouse that someone caught in a sticky trap. Unlike your brother, I knew how to do it. Seriously: use a snap trap, use a live trap, let the cats deal with it, or, best of all, do not leave food out for the mice, rats, and roaches in the first place.
Put yourself in their place, I suppose? Getting snapped is like a hanging. Drowning is semi-quick but takes a bit longer and is not very fun. Glue trap perhaps akin to scaphism and crucifixion and the like?
I had a Rat Terrier. …
No I don’t think I’ll tell that. Not pleasant.
Like hanging using an untrained hangman, maybe. Sometimes snap traps kill instantly; sometimes they don’t. Drowning, OTOH, works every time.
I don’t think it matters all that much. It’s November here in New York. Mice are moving into houses as the outdoor temperatures drop.