People who make the “We have too many people already” forget that a declining population is adverse for an economy which borrowed extensively for repayment by younger generations…
Everything from municipal bonds, home values, and 401k in the US will be impacted by deflation. Even without that debt there is a age shift that dramatically impacts the quality of life for the young members who have to increase productivity to take care of the elderly.
Every single long term economic trend in US history has been fed by immigration or slavery. As an example Irish, Finnish, German and Italians all functioned as the influx of cheap labor for less desirable jobs…and they are all “hated” by nationalists at the time yet their descendants are now considered as the “white” and “acceptable” types now.
As this pattern has repeated several times in America I doubt that this will be the last time it happens. I just hope that we don’t have to resort to a Holocaust for it to end this time (Yes Nordicism and Eugenics were an US export to Nazi Germany)
The other turned into an upstanding citizen who went on to represent Minnesota’s 5th congressional district. She is being touted by the far-right as an example of “how dangerous immigration is”.
Both were children when they showed up. One was (probably, it’s really hard to tell with these things) a burden on the US. One was (probably, it’s really really hard to tell with these things) a boon.
If you’re the man filling out their immigration application… How could you possibly begin to know the answer to these questions?
Yes, this is a simple system. A simple system that is utterly unworkable in practice.
Literally quoted you on this earlier:
Seriously, read the article. Many places in the midwest are thriving explicitly because they took in huge numbers of immigrants. It’s the only way to keep their populations from getting top-heavy (demographic decline is never a good thing for a society). This has basically always been the case throughout US history.
Is this based on actual experience you have in helping refugees relocate to small towns, or just a hunch you have? In any case, it seems likely to me that if such refugees, after relocating, became upstanding members of the community, contributing to it culturally and economically, that people would be glad this happened. That is what I was going for in my response.
I’m having a hard time believing there’s any good-faith argument to be made at all the minimizes or dismisses the threat white supremacy poses. We fought a World War – in fact, the single worst collective event in the history of humanity – to overcome it.
Then again, I never expected my own family would be attacked by a Nazi murderer in 2017. So there’s that data point.
My point is that there are groups of people in the USA who are nonwhite and still at zero risk of being asked for green cards.
Apologies for the delayed reply.
Side note - anyone else remember when someone coming up to you and randomly asking you for your papers was a hallmark of a totalitarian dictatorship in film or literature? I swear it wasn’t that long ago…
DHS adding white power assholes to the watch list.
“The continuing menace of racially based violent extremism, particularly white supremacist extremism, is an abhorrent affront to our nation, the struggle and unity of its diverse population, and the core values of both our society and our department,” said Kevin McAleenan, the acting Homeland secretary, in a speech at the Brookings Institute in Washington.