Why are Eurasian and American beavers so different genetically?

A dash of fluff, couple googly eyes, a sprinkle of Exorcist vibes, and there ya have it. The cutest silent killer nature could make.

Horses and donkeys have a different number of chromosomes, and it isn’t enough to prevent them from interbreeding. But it is enough to prevent their offspring from being fertile.

And even that isn’t a strict guarantee!

Enter Przewalski's horse | Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute :

Przewalski’s horses have 66 chromosomes, compared to the 64 that domestic horses have. It is unusual in that they can produce fertile hybrids with the domestic horse (65 chromosomes) that are able to breed and produce offspring. The hybrids look like Przewalski’s horses, and the only way to identify them is through chromosome testing.

Or more sciency version that explains the mechanism: Przewalski’s horses not ancestors of modern domestic horses | OUPblog (above my head, can’t paraphrase)


Speciation just isn’t as neat a phenomenon as we want it to be, and “can it produce fertile offspring” isn’t as ironclad a test as we once believed.

Speciation is more of a gradient soup than a strict A or B, like mixing colors on a palette and arguing about whether it’s red or maroon.

Female mules can breed a decent chunk of the time (although farmers generally don’t want them to). Male mules apparently never can.

I once asked my biology teacher why we still stick with the Linnean system (the naming scheme where we call a species something like Scientificus namus) if modern understandings of DNA and genetics superseded the older taxonomies.

Why do we keep this antiquated concept of a “species” if animals are more like color combinations, almost like RGB hexadecimal notation in computers — one animal might be a #ATTACCAT and another might be a #ATTACGAT, and they both will sometimes breed with #GCTGATTAs.

He looked at me for a while, pondered it, then moved onto the next question. I guess that’s why we still have “owls” today.

What i read is that it’s not known how often male mules can breed, because they are essentially all neutered before it comes up.

We use it because we need to unambiguously name things. The taxonomy has been replaced by cladistics, with the names wedged into it. Because we still need a way to be specific (double entendre intended).

Genetic drift can do surprising things. Evolution is sometimes more random than selection of the fittest, at least for traits that seem to confer no reproductive advantage or disadvantage. Evolutionary neutral traits (point mutations, genes or groups of genes, number of chromosomes, distribution of the genes in the chromosomes…) can spread like wildfire in a population or simply disappear.

Most of the time, the ancestry determined by genetics is a reasonable match for the old taxonomy based ones, for higher organisms. Owls are a clade; all owls share a common ancestor and all members of that ancestor are owls. The concept of them being one ‘Order’ is an arbitrary label, but they are a nice, consistent group and the Linnaean system works fine.

The problem is for the groups where it doesn’t work well. It was clearly designed for macro-organisms that in general just have a few fuzzy edges and the odd organism that looks like it should be similar to another, but genetically isn’t. The advent of genetics hasn’t actually caused too many major changes to these groups, mostly it’s just tinkering at the edges, the ‘should we call this red or is it maroon’ issue which has been going since the start, with genetics just giving one extra bit of info in the ‘lumper/splitter’ arguments. In general, the fact that different groups could interbreed isn’t really considered all that important if they don’t.

The problems really kick in for microbes; bacteria that regularly swap genes between unrelated lineages, organisms that can’t be grown in single culture so we can’t figure out what’s them and what’s an unrelated bacterium that co-occurs.

So yes, the system of naming is, indeed, an issue. The problem is though, the actual issue is the biology, not the naming. Whatever new system is designed to identify groupings is still going to be faced with the same issue of trying to apply a consistent reliable identification system to something which is by it’s very nature flexible and changing. Scientists actually do use other concepts like a ‘species complex’, for when we know a group of organisms are a group, but no-one can really figure out the boundaries within it, but if the labels get too granular or too fuzzy, they stop being useful, and that’s all the labelling system is, something designed to be useful for humans.

Great clarification! Thank you.

I was going to say that my favorite example of species lines being blurry is gulls. The story as I had heard it was that there were a bunch of gull species all along the shorelines of the northern hemisphere, and that adjacent gull species could mate but species across the sea from each other could not. But apparently new genetic studies have debunked this understanding of gulls.

So… Are the two types of beavers really very different, genetically, or did they both come from a similar ancestor, and one group either split or merged some chromosomes without an enormous change in the underlying genes?

(They sure look similar.)

It sounds to me like it’s the latter. They are believed to have had a common ancestor about 8 million years ago, in Eurasia; what became the American beaver migrated across the Bering land bridge to North America around 7.5 million years ago.

The genomes are about as similar as 2 species could get, having diverged so recently. It’s just recombined onto a different count of chromosomes.

8 million years isn’t THAT recent. On average, a mammalian species lasts for somewhere between 1 to 2 million years between evolving and going extinct.

7 to 8 million years is the average time for a whole mammalian genus to arise and disappear. So Castor is a particularly successful genus, as are both extant species.

Quibbles over the definition of “recent” aside, the broader point is that the genomes of these species aren’t more dissimilar than you’d expect from 2 similar-looking species in the same genus. They have similar genomes, they’re just distributed across a different number of chromosomes.

Chromosome count is an imprecise and unreliable way to intuit relatedness, for reasons seen in this case. A differing count can confirm that the samples aren’t from the same species, but relying on it for other purposes is usually very iffy.

Because “madeira” was not capitalized in your post, I first read this as being about madeira-drinking mice. Party mice!

When I was in Cornwall decades ago, my friend and I were walking back to our B&B on a farm after dinner. I almost felt a small whoosh of air, then, I noticed an enormous barn owl swooping just over our heads. It was very cool. Completely silent.

Eh, well, maybe a drunken mice orgy cult arose from that and caused the genetic isolation over time. Nature is just full of surprises.

Sounds like Ring species - Wikipedia ?

I think the gulls in particular were found to be a false example of that, and the overall theory has been weakened because of it, but it’s still an interesting concept. There’s perhaps not a perfect idealized example of this phenomenon, but the Wikipedia article lists a bunch of less-than-perfect examples.

A line, but not a ring: i don’t think a Chihuahua can naturally breed with a mastiff. But there are intermediate dogs that all can breed with each other.

Ouch…