I don’t have a convertible yet, but I took driver’s ed in one (we only put the top up when it was raining) and I wish to get one in the future. My taste in cars is a bit…um…odd, so I’ll do a point-by-point.
What exactly is the appeal of the convertible automobile?
Fun.
**For starters, they have a higher initial cost than an equivalent hardtop. **
Not an issue for me; the one I want is almost 40 years old (1965 Mercury). Size reference: about as long as a fullsize pickup (123-inch wheelbase).
They’re also less safe than a hardtop, particularly in a rollover
I’ll give you that one, although it’d be hard to roll that wide, low behemoth.
or if you slam into an SUV that rides higher off of the ground.
Again, not an issue for me — it rides as high as most stock SUVs.
They are much noisier, even with the top up.
That’s one of the main reasons I want it. There’s just something about the roar of a big V8 and the wind rushing by…
And your hair gets all messed up if you drive with the top down.
My hair’s too short to get really messed up by the wind (and if it does, simply running my fingers through it will suffice), and I usually put on a hat when I get out of the car.
Structurally, their frames are not as rigid, so they don’t handle as well as hardtops unless the underside is heavily reinforced.
Back in then, they were still building the fullsize cars with a real frame underneath, so it’s about as stiff as the pickup I currently drive. Would probably handle about the same, too (same type of suspension and tire size).
The have more aerodynamic drag, so they’re slower and get worse gas mileage than a hardtop.
With the 390 cid V8, it’ll go plenty fast, and the gas mileage is horrendous anyway (which is fine by me). Science corner: it’s not a whole lot more drag, anyway: one would assume the cabin fills up with a static “bubble” of air, so the only drag is off the back of the windshield, just like a pickup bed (yes, boys and girls, those flowthrough mesh/net/removed tailgates actually hurt your mileage); and any additional drag from that as opposed to a fastback metal roof would be negligible in my case, considering that big parachute of a grille up front.
And then there’s the issue of theft. You might as well just leave the door wide open because anyone with a pocket knife can get inside in just a few seconds.
As has already been said, it’s no more difficult to knock a window out of a hardtop.
And then think of all the dirt and bird poop you get on the roof of your car. Image what it would be like if all of this got on the inside of your car.
Put the top up when parked, and get easily-wiped-with-a-damp-rag leather/vinyl seats for the occasional lucky hit while driving.
So why would anybody want to own such a vehicle?
Because I like the messed-up hair, and the noise, and the wind.
I second the suggestion to test-drive one.