Why is Nvidia so valuable?

If I’ve learned anything from the last decade, it’s “Never meet your heroes. And try not to fuck them, either, no matter how much you like their leather jacket.”

OK, that’s a much better picture than the one I saw.

The Intel CPU architecture has been kluged for so many generations that it is collapsing of its own weight just as AI is demanding huge amounts of number-crunching capability, Nvidia happened to have a chip that did faster number crunching. It seems mostly like a matter of luck being in the right place at the right time.

Choose wisely though. You only get the one freebie.

As someone who used to work for Intel, you are exactly right.
I’ve know about Nvidia chips for a long time. There have been many papers about how researchers used them for parallel processing. They were very good at a product which used to have a fairly small market. It is totally true that their position now is mostly luck with just a bit of skill.

Jensen (as opposed to the other Huang) probably deserves a little more credit than “mostly luck”? Nvidia successfully navigated (and came up on top) several unlikely times:

  • Their birth was difficult, having nearly died if not for a Sega bailout because they believed in Jensen: During Nvidia's formative years, its CEO reckons it 'had a mission statement for a company that has no chance of success' but it was fine because Sega's CEO thought 'Jensen was a young man he liked' | PC Gamer
  • In the 90s and 2000s, they had to beat out ATI, 3dfx, Matrox, etc. They were behind 3dfx, but ended up not only beating but buying 3dfx
  • Through the 2010s and 2020s, they had to compete with AMD’s verticalized integration with ATI and their dominance in the console wars.
  • They made a very early bet on CUDA, back in the days when people still thought of GPU compute mostly as a curiosity, and where most of that sort of parallel processing was happening on PS3 Cell units rather than gaming desktops
  • They revolutionized the use of AI/ML in gaming graphics with DLSS, which spurred every other vendor to create similar implementations
  • CUDA and massively improved GeForce cards positioned them exceptionally well for the crypto boom, which led them straight into the AI boom
  • Intel is still struggling to catch up, both on the gaming graphics front and the AI accelerator front, despite their huge resources

Yes, it took a fair bit of luck and good timing, but also a lot of risky bets and long-term plays that very few other companies would’ve even bet on, much less won.

Nvidia employees are trying to get him to be reinstated, Altman-style, because he’s so valuable to the company: Nvidia employees petition to bring back Jensen Huang | Hacker News

I think Jensen was one of those very few legitimately “visionary” CEOs in the industry… it will be interesting to see where Nvidia goes after this.

A few FLA’s there.

Not at all disputing they make good stuff. But that they became the most valued company in the world (until recently) as opposed to a very successful one was luck.
They’re not the only ones. Intel was lucky that IBM bought their processor and not the better one from Motorola. The exhibit on it at the Intel Museum when I interviewed there pretty much admitted it.

Sorry :slight_smile: Was boarding a plane and didn’t have time to explain. Let me re-English that:

  • Through the 2010s and 2020s, they had to compete with their big competitor AMD’s verticalized integration with another former giant, ATI, and this combined rival’s dominance in the gaming console wars.
  • They made a very early bet on CUDA, their programming interface that allowed their gaming accelerator graphics cards to also be used for general high-powered computing in science, simulations, and other sorts of heavy-duty number crunching. This was back in the days when people still thought of this sort of graphics-card computation mostly as a curiosity, since most real work still happened on a computer’s central processing unit (CPU). There was a parallel to this in the Playstation 3 gaming console, whose specialized processor was found to be excellent at parallelization and ended up being used in ad-hoc supercomputer clusters.
  • They revolutionized the use of early artificial intelligence and machine learning (not in the way we know it today) in gaming graphics with a special gaming accelerating technology called DLSS. It is a way to generate just a few medium-quality frames of an animation, then using AI trickery to upsample them and interpolate them with predicted fake frames. This drastically sped up games at the cost of some visual fidelity, but allowed gamers to run games at much higher graphics settings (or at all) than they otherwise would’ve been able to. This technology was very successful and spurred every other vendor to create similar implementations
  • CUDA (the aforementioned “use graphics card for general computation”) and their massively improved line of GeForce gaming graphics + compute cards positioned them exceptionally well for the cryptocurrency boom, which led them straight into the AI boom

Yeah, that’s probably true. If Google had taken transformers more seriously and utilized their own hardware, they would’ve had a huge head start on Nvidia. But they were afraid of cannibalizing Google Search and slept on it. :man_shrugging:

Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil

J. Paul Getty.

Just boarding a plane? You might have a lot of time to think on this. :slightly_frowning_face:

If Nvidia bought 3DFX, what happened to 3DFX stock?

Nvidia owns it.

Heh, yeah, that was an adventure… turned out OK though. Luckily we happened to have family in the city we got stranded in. We rented a car and decided to make a short weekend road trip out of it, driving home instead of risking another flight.

Speaking of AI, the algorithmic pricing for rental cars was quite terrifying. I booked a one way rental as soon I disembarked, assuming the demand would soon spike. And sure enough, not a few hours later, they became 4x to 6x more expensive.

Glad you got back. I heard on the news that both rental car and hotel prices went through the roof.

I owned some stock in 3dFx. What happened to mine?

Feels like you should be in a good position to answer that? Often there’s a conversion to the new stock.

However, in late 2000,[3][49] not long after the launch of the Voodoo 4,[49] several of 3dfx’s creditors decided to initiate bankruptcy proceedings. 3dfx, as a whole, would have had virtually no chance of successfully contesting these proceedings, and instead opted to sell its assets to Nvidia, effectively ceasing to exist as a company. The resolution and legality of those arrangements (with respect to the purchase, 3dfx’s creditors and its bankruptcy proceedings)[3][49] took over a decade to resolve in the federal courts. Specifically, the trustee of 3dfx’s bankruptcy estate challenged 3dfx’s sale of its assets to Nvidia as an allegedly fraudulent conveyance. On November 6, 2014, in an unpublished memorandum order, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the “district court’s judgment affirming the bankruptcy court’s determination that [Nvidia] did not pay less than fair market value for assets purchased from 3dfx shortly before 3dfx filed for bankruptcy”.[49]

Usually when a company goes bankrupt the stockholders end up with nothing.

These are two different things. One company buying another is a purchase of the stock. Stockholders get to vote on it and if approved, will be compensated, either cash or stock of the buying company.

But selling the assets is not a purchase of the company. Stockholders get no say in the matter. The money they get from the assets goes to the creditors, and if there’s anything left over, to the stockholders. Since 3dFx was in bankruptcy, there is unlikely to be any money left over, so stockholders get nothing. At most they’ll have some worthless stock certificates and most probably don’t even have that.