I tried a french butter dish but in summer the butter goes rancid (we do not have A/C) and in winter the butter stays fine in a regular butter dish, as the kitchen is only heated to about 55F.
I haven’t kept butter on the counter without a heavy cover on it for forty years. Pets.
We have a baseboard heater and a space heater in our kitchen, but we only turn one or the other (or, on rare occasions) both on for the coldest of cold days (think: daytime highs of 20F or below). Further, we hung up a curtain in the little archway separating the kitchen from the rest of the house in order to keep the warm air in the living room from moving into the kitchen (pour one out for energy efficiency, am I right?).
HOWEVER, winters here are somewhat forgiving, and winter days with a high of 50-60F aren’t unheard of.
All of this is to say that, on our “warmer” winter days, it’s not out of the question that our butter will spread on a winter day. Or, conversely, if we felt like heating the kitchen routinely during the winter (it gets warm enough in there when we cook), it could easily spread on any day during the winter.
I do like it, a lot. I use Lurpak Spreadable Butter, which is 23% canola, and I keep it in the fridge. In fact, I keep anything even remotely perishable in the refrigerator, because I live in a place where… let’s just say that it’s December 17 and I’m waiting for winter to start.