I’ve been taking depo-provera for almost 2 years now, and it’s been heavenly! I needed 800mg of codeine (100 at a time) and an antidepressant, compazine, to control vomiting during that week. Nothing helped the migraines. Since depo, I’ve only 1 period, no pain or agony!
I would recommend depo-provera to almost anyone, with one caveat - if you want kids, you should wait at least 6-9 months after being off depo before attempting to become pregnant. Some women who get preggers right way away have birth defects. So if you’re planning on children soon, you should probably hold off.
The New Yorker article was fascinating, I was also intrigued by the various people working on pills that don’t require periods.
I’m not sure why any of this is considered “messing around with nature” to a greater degree than hysterectomies (!) or pills that force your body to 28 day cycle (which may be the average, but is not the natural cycle for many of us.) Since there’s no medical reason why we need a period every 28 days precisely, why not pick a more convenient time, say 90 days, or even 180. Or why not skip it all as bad joke?
As for the whole “where does the blood go” thing - we’re not walking around with bags of blood in side us. There is no “blood” to go anywhere. The tissue of the uterine lining remains intact and doesn’t dissolve. And it’s no more unhealthy than what happens when a breastfeeding woman doesn’t have a period. (In fact, it’s the same thing, from a practical standpoint.)
On the contrary, preliminary studies cited in the links above suggest that the constant creation of a new lining each month, as well as the monthly swelling of breast tissue, accounts for the higher incidences of breast and uterine cancer in countries where the pill is commonly used (since more cell division = more chances for a dangerous mutation).
In other words, rather than being healthy and natural, the monthly period forced by common pills might be more dangerous than yearly periods.
The important thing, I guess, is to find the option that’s best for you. And if you want periods every 28 days, (shrug) ok. But the only “natural” option is to skip BC altogether and just take whatever your body gives you.