As the guy who started this trend of a new thread for each expansion, way back when, I want to say that, for the first time since 2008, I found myself simply not caring about a new expansion. Shadowlands finally killed the game for me.
In every previous expansion, some of which I loved to death and some not so much, I enjoyed the questing at the very least. I always found that part of the game well done and fun. But the questing in Shadowlands just felt like a chore to me. And then, upon reaching max level, there was the new chore of having six (I suspect I exaggerate) new currencies to start grinding out. Completely unrewarding World Quests, relative to their difficulty.
I got seven classes to max level in Cata, nine in MoP, and then at least one of every class to max in WoD, Legion, and BfA. I got one character to max in SL before throwing in the towel, because it just wasn’t fun any more. Too much unnecessary (IMHO) artificial difficulty in just the basic stuff that tended more toward “frustrating” and “tedious” than toward “challenging”.
I’m pretty much sticking with the resurrected City of Heroes over at Homecoming.
The story there: I started WoW 2-4 weeks after the launch of Wrath. Loved the hell out of that expansion. Only maxed three characters: my human ret paladin main, my draenei fire mage, and my blood elf ret pally.
Cata came along, and I was one who loved the revamp to the questing that made it more solo friendly. But then, at max level, and being a non-raider, I found there just wasn’t much of anything to do besides making the same circuit of daily quests every day. I got seven alts to 85, and just doing the same round of dailies on all of them every day got boring. I was also irritated that Blizzard seemed intent on forcing everybody who played a hybrid class to switch to tanking and healing. My shadow priest replaced my fire mage as my main spellcaster, because the changes they made to fire completely wrecked my preferred playstyle.
I expressed some wish on here that there was some other MMO out there that would run on a Mac, as I was a Mac user at the time. Somebody pointed me at City of Heroes, so I headed over there and signed up. I fell in love with it quickly, and canceled my WoW sub almost as quickly. Alas, NCSoft decided to completely shut the game down just a year or so later.
Fortunately, the shutdown coincided roughly with the release of Mists of Pandaria, and I ended up loving the hell out of that expansion. Fun from beginning to end.
Warlords of Draenor started out tons of fun, then dropped off quickly, but I mostly enjoyed it to the end.
Legion was, for me, insanely fun. And the announcement that Blizz was going to finally end support for OpenGL with the launch of BfA finally forced me to upgrade by switching to a new Windows gaming PC. I’d been playing from 2008 to 2018 on the same iMac, having to lower my graphics settings with every new expansion to keep the game playable.
I mostly enjoyed BfA. But I was really annoyed with the way professions worked, particularly being forced into dungeons to advance freaking gathering professions. Oh swell, I have to kill several dungeon bosses in order to learn a better method for picking flowers. Blizzard introducing new things that I totally loved (warfronts), only to discontinue them because the hardcore raiders complained about them. I think the same thing happened to scenarios in previous expansions.
Then came the surprise announcement that, somehow, City of Heroes was back from the dead. I instantly unsubbed from WoW and made a Homecoming account in May 2019. I played the hell out it, loving every minute. Then came the 2020 Covid lockdowns, leaving me stuck at home with nothing much to do except play CoH for hours and hours (and also buying a new electric guitar and relearning how to play it, after being almost exclusively a bass player for the previous 30+ years). I ended up getting a bit burned out, largely because I was rolling tons of alts which meant that I was playing the same low-level content over and over and over. So I took a break and re-subbed to WoW in order to see the end of BfA and the beginning of Shadowlands.
A couple months of Shadowlands was all it took for me to finally throw in the towel on WoW. Went back to CoH, and haven’t looked back. Homecoming gives me 1000 character slots (per server!), so right now I’m up to 127 completely unique alts, and counting.