My favorite poem of all time is “Tenderness” by Stephen Dunn. I won’t type it here and it’s not availible on the internet, but I encourage everyone to look it up sometime. Dunn won a Pulitzer Prize for Different Hours, but I think Between Angels, which “Tenderness” is in, is far more worthy.
Also, “Bill’s Story” by Mark Doty is a sad, haunting, lovely masterpiece about a woman dying of AIDS. “Heaven” and “Brilliance” are also incredible poems. All are availible in My Alexandria, one of the most amazing collections of poetry ever, by any poet.
I love Eliot as well, but my favorite poem of his (and definitely in my top five list of all-time favorites) is “Marina”, part of which follows:
Sigh. It gives me goose bumps, it is so lovely.