For rock music, I’ve given it a lot of thought over the years.
Who has the best combination of voice, skill, and (most importantly) attitude? Who exemplifies the real essence of R&R?
I really like Rob Halford, but there’s no hint of humor in his mannerism or the music. (And I really think there needs to be some lightheartedness, if not subtle humor, in rock music.) Freddie Mercury and RJD? Operatic. I don’t think rock music should be operatic.
So with that being said, the very best rock singer, in my opinion, was Bon Scott.
That’s not a bad choice, but I thought of two singers who can hold a candle, especially in that heavier category: Ian Gillian, who is (or was, he can’t reach that high anymore) the best shouter ever in rock, and Chris Cornell, who had exceptional pipes. But for me, the most skilled rock singer ever is Mike Patton. He can sing everything, hard rock, crooning, sweet soul, rap, cookie monster style, often in one song. He’s a phenomenon.
Yea, skill. To each his own, but I think attitude and hints of humor are also important. With the exception of punk rock, most rock singers possess neither attribute. Hence Bon Scott.
Oh yes, I appreciate humor, and I confess that some of my most favorite bands lack it, and Bon had a lot of it. Mike Patton has it, too.
I will definitely check out Norm Lewis. Thanks for the recommendation.
I’d forgotten that McDonald and Mitchell were both in the original Ragtime. I did not see it on Broadway, but my daughter did–I think she was about 13?–and loved it. I believe she saw both of them in that performance. I have the recording of the show and need to listen to it again soon.
Yes, Gypsy in particular was something else–one of the two top theatrical experiences I have had, and McDonald was absolutely astonishing. I was privileged to be there!
I think Freddie Mercury is in the running for best singer that’s ever lived. I can’t hate on that choice. But even though I love Queen, Freddie is not my favorite singer. My favorite singers are much less technically skilled than Freddie, but I just love their voices.
I think her phrasing is flawless.
So many, and a lot who’ve already been referenced. So I’ll go a personal fave I didn’t see above and nominate the plaintive dirge of Townes Van Zandt, particularly on Waitin’ Around to Die and Our Mother the Mountain. He really makes you feel the music.