MaryAnne, Gilligan when come back, bring pie

Beckdawrek
Mon, 13 Apr 2026 02:04:53 +0000
Cafe Society

First season episode #25 ‘Physical fitness’.
Skipper needs to lose weight for a hilarious (?)reason.
Gilligan needs to gain weight and strength. Similiar reasons.

So MaryAnne being the nurturer she is make pies. Lots of pie.

Coconut cream
Banana cream.
Yum—my.

I said she made more banana cream pie.
Everyone else says coconut cream pie.

First off, who makes coconut cream pie? It’s just pudding with coconut in. Or actual creamed coconut?
I don’t think Maryanne had the facilities to “cream” coconut on the island.

I say banana cream pie would be much simpler.

But then there’s no Nilla wafers.
And they might’ve had a problem with milk products.

They might’ve had plantains which might be an issue.

Seems I better stick to fresh fruit on the island. No pie

(I looked Coconut cream pie was the most mentioned in Gilligan canon, ok, So I’m wrong!)

61 posts - 21 participants