Have I missed a thread about this somewhere else?
I’m speechless…
Nah. Just another urban legend.
I think we had a thread about this at one point, but I can’t remember where (here or the Pit) or when. In any event, Snopes debunks it pretty thoroughly. (If the link doesn’t bring you straight to the page, look under their “Rumours of War” section.
Sua
Or just follow Mr. Visible’s link.
Sua
Hm.
So the French Guy wrote a book about an UL and not only got it published but had a “hit” in France, and now they’re bringing it to the States?
Great.
But is it significant that that Snopes page was last updated on April Fool’s Day…??!!!
Sister Coyote, he didn’t write about the urban legend; he created it. What we have here is a valuable case study in conspiracy theory creation. We’ve been able to watch this one develop from the start, and I’m pretty convinced that this one is going to stick around for decades.
It’s got all the hallmarks; examination of incomplete evidence to bolster a predetermined theory, rejection of any claims to the contrary, no matter how well-based on evidence, complete lack of explanation as to why this conclusion is close to as plausible as the accepted one… you get the idea.
It’s like a ChiaPet for the ages. Sit back and watch it grow.
Here is the GQ thread SuaSponte just mentioned, which has some additional info even beyond the Snopes article.
Now let’s see if the new sig works . . .
All other evidence that the book is full of crap aside, I find it hard to believe that a lone Frenchman would be able to unravel a real conspiracy AND write a well-documented book about it in well under a year’s time.
Also, I’ve never jumped on the senseless “hate the French” bandwagon, but if they’re really that stupid, gullible, and prepared to believe the worst about us…
Eh…it’s the French. What do you expect?
Most French folk don’t actually believe what the book says, even if they buy it. It’s more for the entertainment value of indulging in wild conspiracies and fantasies; Americans aren’t exactly immune from this, as tabloids do very well in the States. The book is just a lengthy, hard-cover tabloid.
- Wind
His next book will be about the brilliant French military tactics of World War II.