CEI Ads: "Carbon Dioxide. We call it life."

Scared into a fit of stupidity over the new Al Gore movie, An Inconvenient Truth, the Competitive Enterprise Institute has developed some ads to counter the message of the film. Their message is summed up at the end with the tagline: “Carbon dioxide. They call it pollution. We call it life.”

If I didn’t know better, I’d say that these ads were a parody from some group like The Onion. Since it’s so great for “life,” which is the message these ads would like to convey, I’d like to see the creators of these ads sit in a roomful of carbon dioxide.

Stupid fuckers. If “pollution is good” is the best counter argument you’ve got, from what I hear, Al Gore’s movie is going to kick your ass.

While it’s not commonly known, CEI is actually run by intelligent plants.

The Frodis is now a corporate PR flack? Wow, the Sixties really are over.

Yeah, this kind of plant me thinks…

I’m trying to be outraged, but really that’s just hilarious.

{{{{ CO[sub]2[/sub] }}}}
You’ve saved me from a world of backbreaking labor, and lit up my life.
I love you, carbon dioxide. :stuck_out_tongue:

I wondered what the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company was doing promoting CO[sub]2[/sub].

I had not previously encountered the Competitive Enterprise Institute.

To smarter people it is funny, but I am sure there is somebody out there that “this just makes sense” to. Truthiness.

Did you know that Jesus exhaled carbon dioxide? And there’s a good chance you’ve picked a flower, or even taken a breath that held just a little bit of his holy effluence.

I honestly think that the ads are actually a guerilla marketing campaign to promote Gore’s new movie. It just can’t be possible that anyone with any marketing acumen whatsoever could produce something so laughable.

Bastard. Why do you hate carbon dioxide?

Didn’t anyone realize that the CEI is a shell corporation for the League of Dry Ice Enthusiasts?

Seems like a lot of corporate trade groups have decided to go on the offensive against things they feel are hurting their industry. These ads are up all over DC, for instance: http://www.fishscam.com/

The problem with these ads is that they just don’t contain enough scary misinformation. What happened to, “If CO2 is declared a pollutant, the government could fine you just for breathing, or confiscate any sources of it they find in your home. You know what’s a big CO2 producer? Your baby.”

Or, how about this:

(As a theremin drones softly, the camera is “walking” in an empty room which is painted a brilliant white, with many white pillars. Voiceover.)

“They wait (beat) out of sight, in the extreme north and south of the planet.”

(A sudden rustle. The camera POV whirls to find – nothing.)

“They weigh millions of tons. They do not reason. They don’t feel pain, or love, or remorse.”

(Three-quarter second flash cut – Arnold Schwartzeneggar as the Terminator)

“They care not for art, for religion, for civilization --”

(Cut to montage : paintings, cathedrals, cities – upward looks at tall buildings only)

“They are glaciers, and the last time they came for us, half the American landscape was simply – erased…”

(Wipe montage – white screen)

“…leaving us literally in the Stone Age.”

(Cut to cavemen getting stomped by mastodon)

“If they come again – and scientists tell us they will – there is nothing on Earth that can stand in their way. Except for --”

(Cut to little girl blowing a string of bubbles. Hold on the flight of last bubble)

“CO2.”

(Slow sequence: wood fire, steam locomotive, steel mill, oil well, 405 freeway approaching LAX, jetliner taking off)

“Some call it air pollution, some call it smog, but CO2, the stuff of a little girl’s innocent breath, has been keeping glaciers at bay for ten thousand years. And as American industry has become more efficient at converting natural resources into CO2, we are not merely holding our own…”

(Cut to before-and-after pix of shrunken ice cap)

“…but winning!”

(Cut to shot of some guy, waiting to cross a busy street, getting a face full of bus exhaust. At first he looks irritated, then thoughtful, then smiles broadly)

“So the next time you encounter CO2, take the time to enjoy it. Breathe deep, and tell yourself, ‘I smell victory.’ Don’t savor it too long, though. Blow it out again, and if you feel like it add some CO2 of your own. We need every bit we can get to fight the glaciers.”

You know, you get yourself a handheld video camera, and a few yards of stock footage, and you could pitch that to The Colbert Report.

I don’t see what the problem is with the ads. I think that the message they are trying to get across is that we take our technology for granted. I get so frustrated when I here someone say that we are “addicted” to oil, as if it were some recreational drug that only provides superficial benefits.

We are addicted to oil in as much as we are addicted to farming, they are invaluable technologies that we can not currently live with out. But that seems to be forgotten to often in debates on ecology.
Yeah, CO2 is not life, but the technologies that produce it are and are currently irreplacable.

Actually, it looks like their message is quite obviously, “CO2 is a wonderful part of nature, it is silly to think that making more of it is bad.”

Whether you call it an addiction or a dependency doesn’t matter with respect to the ad. With their logic you wouldn’t even want to reduce CO2 emissions which keeping the same level of industry.

Argh, while keeping the same…

I don’t think that that is their message at all.

“I’m in denial about environmental issues, and I vote!”