so bit 12 why no editing

to be edited?

http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showpost.php?p=7697053&postcount=12

And this brings up another - if a thread is too old for your answers to be “edited” is it automatically considered a necro thread, not to be bumped, updated, etc (usual exclusions apply of just linking necro threads in a new thread) …

:confused:

You have a rule/explaination, delimited as 12 (the number after 11, but before 12.000000000000000000000000001).

It says ‘why can’t we edit our posts’ and goes on for a bit about flame wars and he said she said crap ya’ll didn’t want to deal with.

Is self edit a test? Permanent? Something to bog the server down with until another mod or admin melts down in a pile of pixels?

If it is permanent, are you going to edit that rule\post?

Does this new ability to edit for a certain amount of time also act as a rule of thumb for necro post bumping?

If I need to be more clear, please provide a more detailed explanation of confusion.

I can no longer edit my first post.

So - can’t edit doesn’t mean “too old to bump”. Got it. I poked around and didn’t see mention of a timer, so I asked.

Dex addresses some of your questions here.

And FYI, I’m not one of the “y’all”, I just post here and occasionally write Staff Reports.

Can’t be a little bit pregnant, but can be a little bit ‘da man’? I guess if you have no editing powers or admin powers but are just a content provider for their Web 2.5 scheme ala SomethingAwful, you are just a subcontractor for ‘da man’?

I guess some would say there is a difference, there. :stuck_out_tongue:

Need to work on my reading comprehension, too; thanks for the link.

Everyone, continue experimenting! I am so easily amused by the antics of the hour.

Something like that. I’m just one of their typewriter monkeys. :wink:

Gah! Demand a computer! Do you have to (shudder) send in paper submissions? Ewwwww … how 19th century!

Skunk as a drunk again, are you? :slight_smile:

If onleeeeeeeeeeeeee - just lacking sleep.

Have fun!

We had the rule of “no editing” because of what was said in the explanation: see Rules for Posting at the Straight Dope Message Board and note post #12. Plus, it put too much strain on our already over-taxed old server(s).

The question came up every so often for discussion. There was a thread two weeks ago about this: Is there any way to edit or remove your own post? - About This Message Board - Straight Dope Message Board At that time, we were considering a trial of editing with the new server, but didn’t dare say anything because folks get all upset if they hear what we think might happen.

So, we’re on a trial basis. We do listen to you. If it works out, we’ll revise the rules, but I don’t want to go to that much trouble if it lasts a week and then vanishes from abuse.

… and I hope to heaven this doesn’t mean that every other post is of the “nyah, nyah, you mispelled a word.” [sub]Yes, I know, it’s deliberate, it’s a joke on Gaudere’s Principle.[/sub]

You have five minutes from the time you first hit the button. And that’s it.