Sex of Third and Subsequent Kids: A Poll

This is a spinoff from this thread

There doesn’t seem to be any online data regarding predispositions in a family one way or another towards girls or boys. And I find the question interesting enough to do a little statistical sampling of my own. So here’s the poll:

[ul]
[li]think of all the families you know with 3 or more kids, born to the same 2 parents.[/li][li]Throw out all cases where you don’t know all ages and sexes, or where the first two are different sexes (keep in cases like BBGB or GGGBG)[/li][li]List the rest. Just for extra interest, bold your and/or partners birth family, and italicise family of which you are a parent, if relevant.[/li][/ul]

If there are enough responses, I’ll do some analysis after a while and see if we come up with anything interesting.

Here goes me:

GGB
BBB
GGG
GGG
GGGB
BBBB
BBG
BBGB
BBBBB
GGGG
GGGGG
GGG
GGG
GGB
GGB

This won’t be a random sample, so you can’t draw any inferences about the general population from it.

In what direction do you think it will be biased? And why?

any letters unseperated are twins

G|G|B
B|B|B
B|B|G
G|G|B|G|G|G
G|B|G
G|B|B
G|G|GG
G|B|GB
B|B|G
G|B|B
G|B|B

ggb
bbbgbb

ggb
bbg
bbgb

“Sex of Third” was my Borg name.

Maybe I’m missing something, but if you throw out those cases don’t you kind of ruin the results?

g/g/g/g
b/b/b
b/b/g/b
g/g/g/b/g/g/g/b

If you look at the original GQ thread, the question is what the probability of having a specific sex child are if you already have two of the same sex

I know a bunch of 3+ families (sometimes +++). Many of these are from my mom’s family - has twelve siblings (the top list), who average nearly six kids apiece plus many grandkids - so this is in no way a random sample. The 172 direct biological descendants of my grandparents whose gender I can think of (I’m a little hazy with about five of my cousins’ kids, and I’m leaving out the adoptees and stepkids) are 52.9% male, 47.1% female. None of these are my or my husband’s immediate family, and we have no kids as yet.

The requirements exclude a bunch of heavily-weighted-towards-one-gender families that I know, such as that of a former roommate who was the eldest child of eight, and the only girl.

GGBBGBBBBBGGB
BBB
BBGGGGG
BBB
BBG
BBB
GGGB
BBB
GGB
GGBBBGGGBGGB
BBGGBBG
BBBBBG
GGGBBGB
GGBBGBBBBBGGB
GGGG
BBBBB
GGG
BBG
BBBGG
GGG
BBB
GGGG
GGGB
GGB
BBGB
BBG
GGB
BBB
GGGB
GGG
BBBB
BBGG
GGB
BBB
BBBB

I could probably go on, but that’s enough for now.

BBBB
GGG
GGGGB
BBB
BBB
BBBG
BBBB
BBGB
GGB

My husband and I are onlies but I have 12 cousins. Two of them are girls.

GGBG
GGBG
BBB
BBG
GGB
BBB
BBBBB

That’s all I can think of right now. I know some bigger families, but I have no idea in what order they were born

My children:
BBGGB (Girl 2 was stillborn - does that count?)

A neighbour’s family:
GGGB

BBBBBBBB (Eight boys for my cousin)

My kids went B B G

What’s wrong with those where the first two are different genders, why throw out all those? Is it “just” to shrink the sample? To me, it appears to be skewing it as well. Even if the original question was about third child gender with two repeats, we’re throwing out the “GBBBBB” cases.

BBBB
GGGGGGGGGGBB – she had a lot of abortions between 6 and 7, no idea of genders
GGGGB
BBBBG
BBB – if you add the stillborn girls, it becomes GBBGB
BBB
BBGG
BBBGBBBBBG
GGG
GGGGB

Those are the ones I can remember with 100% certainty off the top of my head.

Bbg
ggbb
ggbb
ggg
ggg
bbg
bbg

ggb
bgg
bbb
gbb
bgb

Ggg
bbbbbb
bbggbbggbbgg
ggb
bbb
bgbbbgb
gbg
bbb

ggg
bbbg
bbgb
ggggb