Cecil –
In your generally well-informed February '03 column exploring the cause of the cataclysmic Tunguska Event of June 30th, 1908, you note the following possible explanation in passing:
QUOTE:
5. It was a black hole. Proposed by two American scientists in 1973, this theory is dismissed by most other investigators as hopelessly naive.
:UNQUOTE
Well, Al Jackson and Mike Ryan (the “two American scientists” in question) might have been wrong, maybe – but “hopelessly naive”? This particular characterization seems to have been drawn from the remarks of Academician Nikolai Vasil’ev, as quoted in Roy Gallant’s book The Day The Sky Split Apart (Atheneum 1995, p. 122). And Vasil’ev’s only substantive objection seems to have been the same one put forward by Bill Beasley and Brian Tinsley back in 1974. Namely, that the so-called “exit event” predicted by Jackson-Ryan – an equally cataclysmic explosion as the black hole erupted up out of the North Atlantic later that same day – never took place.
But the past three decades have seen enough advances in black-hole studies (Hawking radiation and “black monopoles,” to name a couple) to raise the ghost of a chance that Al and Mike might be vindicated yet (and, trust me, that might not be a good thing!).
In any case, there’s a new website <http://www.vurdalak.com> about to fire up on Wednesday, June 30th – just in time for the 96th anniversary of the Tunguska Event. It’s devoted to a detailed re-examination of the Jackson-Ryan hypothesis, and a new spin on that old theory called “The Vurdalak Conjecture.”
So, check it out, Cecil. It might not convince you, but it at least promises to enlighten and entertain. – And it is the “Straight Dope”!
Jenkoul