Minor spoilers ahead, about various British shows that have replaced most or all of their cast from time to time.
It just happened to me yet again. I was catching up on the latest series of Misfits, which had already written off most of the original characters and replaced them with less interesting replacements, and boom. The last remaining original was killed off in a cheesy, hastily written way that he totally didn’t deserve. No buildup, no resolution. Just, “Oh, we’re going to kill him off now.” Argh!
This happens to SO MANY British shows! It drives me nuts. Let’s list some that were either ruined or seriously hurt by cast replacements, off the top of my head: MI-5/Spooks, Misfits, Becoming Human, Hustle, Monarch of the Glen, even effing Are You Being Served. Dr Who, of course, is the unique example of a show that manages to turn the constant turnover into a strength. There are tons more I’m forgetting.
The thing is, once the shedding of actors starts, it becomes a nonstop distraction that prevents the show from actually telling interesting stories. Especially because there are so few episodes per series, each show is either about getting rid of an old character, introducing a replacement, or both. Spooks was particularly bad about that, as I recall. You never get time to actually get interested in the new people because anyone who’s not dying or getting started has to get shoved into the background while we focus on that episode’s cast change. And suddenly you’re watching a whole other show about a whole other group of people, and you can’t help but feel that it’s an inferior copy.
I think Monarch of the Glen had some of the most poorly done replacements. It’s been a few years since I watched it, and I wasn’t that big a fan to begin with, so forgive my memory. As I recall, series 1 revolved around a love triangle, with the main character bouncing between woman A and woman B, all building up to the dramatic climax where he chooses woman A and they decide to get married. YAY! Then series two starts, and off screen, woman A had taken a job in New Zealand or something equally ridiculous, and he had decided that woman B was the better option after all. Ridiculous. And it just got worst from there. We didn’t watch much more of it.
I guess I don’t get why this is such a problem over there. Why are actors all so eager to bail out of a successful show? Are lucrative acting jobs that much more common over there? Are TV jobs really badly paid? I’ve heard that in the US, when a new show is picked up, all of the actors are signed to a standard 7-year contract, so if it lasts that long, they’re guaranteed the same cast. I don’t know why that works here and not in the UK. Given the fewer episodes made per year, it seems like it would less burdensome to have a contract like that in the UK. I don’t know. But sort it out, blast it!