[QUOTE=Sattua]
I am back at 180 today–the 179 was just a fluke due to fluid loss.
I knew it wouldn’t work. Core isn’t substantially different from the way I was eating before …
[/QUOTE]
At the risk of you considering my feedback a “lecture” again (for which I will not apologize), I must say that I still don’t see where you’ve done the real homework necessary in figuring out a plan that will work for you.
You first mentioned starting the WW program when you joined this thread about two weeks ago, so I would agree that you are justified in fiddling with your approach: if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it; if it is broke, fiddle with it. However you have posted from nearly day one about how you “didn’t think it would work” without giving any reason why, except eventually to comment how you were eating pretty much the same calories and doing the same amount of exercise as before.
If you reviewed the WW Core plan, and noticed that the way you would go about it was not really any different than the way you lived your life now… Why would you expect magical results?
A change in your body will only come from a change in your diet and lifestyle, and only you know what the current input values are. A WW plan that doesn’t change those basic input values will not yield a change in your body composition. Just shelling out $$$ to Weight Watchers doesn’t do a thing (except increase their revenue). WW can help you form the shell of your approach, a starting point for your plan, but you must fundamentally accept that you yourself, not an external “they” nor the people contributing to this discussion on the SDMB, are responsible for understanding your body and forming and executing your plan.
OK, “lecture” over; here’s some constructive feedback: if you’re already in calorie balance, you need to consume fewer calories or burn off more calories. Rather than eating less, try exercising more; if you’re already doing regular exercise (you mentioned having “3 or 4 activity points” in your ledger already), try upping the difficulty, increasing the duration or changing the venue.
Cheer up: unless you’re one of the unfortunate few with thyroid issues or something, losing weight is not rocket science, but a well understood problem… Just one with a million different specific solutions. Eventually you WILL find a plan that works for you. But you will have to do real work to figure that plan out, or else trust to luck by using someone else’s plan that happens to approximate what will work for you.