[QUOTE=Madd Maxx]
IOW you don’t know anything about football, but you think the Texans are better than the Eagles. This year I probably agree with you on that count. The biggest problem is that the AFC South is basically 2 expansion teams and two teams that have been moved to their current locations (One of which isn’t even using their old name anymore.) The teams in the NFC East are established football powers since basically the begining. Hell, the Cowboys are the youngest team in our divsion and they have have been in the NFL since 1960.
Records for the past three years:
AFC South 2007: 42-22
NFC East 2007: 40-24
AFC South 2006: 34-30
NFC East 2006: 32-32
AFC South 2005: 32-32
NFC East 2005: 36-28
Combined wins for each division over those 3 years, 108 wins each. The Colts won in 06, but the Giants won last year. Technically a draw, but I’m still right.
[/QUOTE]
Who gives a shit how long they’ve been around? It doesn’t make a damn bit of difference to Team W whether teams X, Y and Z have been in the league for forty years- what matters is whether X, Y and Z are any good.
The NFC East had three playoff teams last year by virtue of luck and the rest of the NFC sucking. The '07 Skins were poor, and must have found a rabbit’s foot shaped like a four-leaf clover or something. The Eagles were terrible. The Giants were terrible at times and pretty good at times- and there’s no way in hell you can argue with a straight face that they were the best team in the league, Superbowl or not. Only the Cowboys were consistently good.
In the AFC South, the Colts were excellent, the Jaguars were excellent, the Titans were decent, and the Texans were mediocre- and might have been quite good if not for losing their two best offensive players for half a season. More to the point, the AFC South sent three teams to the playoffs in the AFC, which is a hell of a lot better than the NFC.
The best division in football isn’t the one with the most history. It’s the one with the best teams- and the NFC East doesn’t have them. Anyone who thinks that a given won-lost record in the NFC is equivalent to the same record in the AFC doesn’t know anything about football.