More frozen CO2? It melted and suffocated him?
The room was perfectly safe when his hosts left him for the night.
Or: no. ![]()
**A man was traveling from Switzerland to his home in France by train. If he had been in a non-smoking car he would have died. Why? **
Hey, man!
LHOD:
Was the man poisoned?
Did he have any visible wounds when the body was discovered?
Did he inadvertently bring anything dangerous into the room with him?
Mahaloth:
Did anyone else on the train die?
Was the train itself damaged in any way?
Are the windows on the train relevant?
- Yes
- No
- No
Sorry!! I’ll wait. My bad.
Let’s do one at a time. I’ll answer this after we finish the current one that I obviously didn’t see on the last page. ![]()
His lover killed him.
**Did his lover poison him before he got to the house where he stayed?
Was he poisoned at dinner that night?
Was the poison taken in by food?**
- was the lover human?
- is the New Year’s Eve time frame critical, or could this have happened any old night?
- was the door locked from the inside, as suggested by the narrative or is there something peculiar about the way the door locks?
- does the room have a chimney?
- No.
- No.
- No.
- Can you rephrase this question?
- Yes.
- Yes.
- Yes–but it’s blocked.
One more note, which may work as a hint: I got this puzzle from a Games Magazine a few decades ago. I’ve spent a bit of time Googling to make sure this murder method could work, and I’ve not come up with anything certain one way or another.
-
Is everyone in this story a human being?
-
Is the fact it is New Year’s Eve relevant?
-
Could this have happened any other night?
-
Was the poison breathed in?
Did the murder method involve a new year’s kiss?
1: Did he drink champagne on New Year’s Eve?
2. If so, was the champagne positioned?
3. Was the psycho ex at the NYE party?
- Yes (and above when I asked about rephrasing the question, I meant to ask this about the New Year’s question, not the human question. Sorry!)
- Yes
- Yes, if you mean it could have happened on other nights. Unlikely, if you mean it could have happened on any random night.
- Yes
No
- No
- No
- No
Was poison gas pumped into the room?
Were fireworks involved in this murder?
Was the chimney blocked to keep poison gas in?
- …I’m gonna say “yes.”
- No
- No
With that, I’m off to bed; I’ll check in tomorrow morning!
My recap, which could be wrong. Please check.
On New Year’s Eve, which is relevant, a poisonous gas was pumped into a locked room and killed a guy. His lover, who was not there, did it(or arranged it).
So we have to figure out:
- how NY Eve plays into this situation
- how his lover managed to get gas into the room
Would anyone else who had been in the room also have died?
Was the victim poisoned at midnight?
[chemistry nitpick]
Maybe he died of the bends? The room would have to be at more than 5 atmospheres for frozen CO2 to melt. At normal atmospheric pressure it would sublime (go directly from solid to gas.)
[/chemistry nitpick]