Anyone know any good "situational puzzles"?

Yes, I know. These things are a bit out dated, but I tried one today with the kids I teach. They loved it!

I did the old, “man walks into bar, orders a drink, has a gun pulled on him…” one. After about 15 minutes, one kid actually answered it(lucky guess!).

If you are unfamiliar with these, try this link: Situational Puzzles

People can ask “yes and no” questions and try to solve the puzzle.

The kids all asked me for more of these and I thought I’d have fun challenging them in the next few weeks.

Anyone know of any of these that are good? :slight_smile:

If you can track down a copy, the game Crack The Case is based on this type of puzzle. Lots of fun too. Here are some details:

http://www.angelfire.com/games/zombiereviews/reviews/crackthecaservw.html

Mind Trap has a lot of excellent puzzles like this as well.

Interesting Slacker. The cheapest I found it on Amazon was 59 and as high as over 200. eBay has it for less, but I was too lazy to do the bidding thing.

Mahaloth, google for Lateral thinking, there are a few sites devoted to these puzzles.

I invented one of these once and posted it here. I can repost it if you’re interested.

There’s a cabin on a mountain. Inside the cabin, there are two dead men. How did they die?

It’s an airplane cabin. The two men were the pilot and co-pilot, and they died when they crashed into the mountain.

There’s the whole book series, *Stories With Holes. * This is what my 5th-grade teachers used as their source for such puzzles.

http://www.storieswithholes.com

Absolutely.

By the way, do a lot of them have dead people in them? It’s seventh grade, but the kids might get tired of “murder” mysteries.

A mountain has a tunnel with a single train track running through it. One day at exactly noon, two trains enter the tunnel from opposite ends. Neither one changes its speed but they pass through the tunnel without crashing. How?

WAG - Difference in time zones at different ends?

A man walks into a restaurant and is shown to a table. He does not look at the menu, but instead orders albatross. The food comes out and he takes one bite. He immediately gets up, walks out of the restaurant, and kills himself by shooting himself in the head. Why?

A man is pushing his car along a street, stops outside a hotel, and realizes he is bankrupt.

Clues:

The car is working as designed

He had to stop there, although he wasn’t tired

If he hadn’t stopped there, he wouldn’t have been bankrupt

It’s a very small car

An inch or so long, in fact

Answer

He is playing Monopoly.

Hm, too bad you don’t want death. The only one I can think of offhand is:

A man is found dead in a room. He hanged himself from a pipe running overhead, and his feet are a foot above the floor. There’s a puddle of water underneath him. The room is otherwise completely empty. There is no furniture, boxes, or any kind of object he could have stood on while hanging himself. How did he do it?

He brought in a block of ice and stood on it. It melted afterwards.

Sometimes these are called lateral thinking puzzles. Here is another page of them

Gah!

I hate these!

How is the spoilered answer in any sense the “right” answer except for the fact that you declare that it is the right answer?

-FrL-

I bet that’s the right answer, and I like that puzzle much more than the one I quoted in my previous post.

There’s something compelling about the answer to this one, somehow.

-FrL-

All right, pop quiz. Airport, gunman with one hostage. He’s using her for cover; he’s almost to a plane. You’re a hundred feet away…

What do you do?
(sorry)

I think that the Q & A part must lead people to the one contemplated answer, because otherwise I agree: Why couldn’t the answer be “They were eaten by bears?”

A man leaves home. After making a couple of stops, he heads back home. But blocking his path is another man wearing a mask.

What’s going on?

Yes, the idea is usually to elicit the specific situational information, not to merely produce any plausible answer. Sort of an expanded 20 questions, where the answer is a (possibly very simple) story, rather than a single item.