Let me first say that I don’t drink, nor do I use any kind of intoxicants for fun (albeit, I think pot should be legal, and alcohol should remain so).
Second, I know I am going to get a lot of flak for this, but the idea that anyone who has been addicted to something and quit must never ever touch it again is entirely theory-based. That is to say, the goal of AA and the majority of rehab clinics being abstinence was based pretty much on the fact that the founder of AA thought it was the only thing that would work for him. There was never research into the idea for decades-- which was fine as long as AA was a personal choice, but people get court-ordered to it, and to rehabs that adopt its philosophies, while insurance pays for them.
A lot of alcoholics I know who treat AA like a religion have a “No true Scotsman” attitude toward any alcoholic who quits and then later becomes a moderate or “social” drinker. “They were never REALLY an alcoholic in the first place”-- never mind that a doctor diagnosed them as one according to whatever DSM was in use at the time, prescribed rehab, and insurance paid for it.
Last, when someone finally did get around to controlled studies of the question, it appeared to be a coin-toss whether a diagnosed alcoholic could ever become a moderate drinker.
I read about the study a good 20 years ago, so I’m assuming it sparked some research since, in trying to predict who could become a moderate drinker, and who could not, but I have never looked that up.
All that said, I am not postulating recreational opiate use for anyone, no matter what their history-- I am just suggesting that prior addiction is not as delicate a state as perhaps previously thought-- and certainly not so delicate that anyone should be expected to forgo pain relief after surgery or a broken bone.
But, even then, there has been and continues to be lots of research into opiate alternatives, and I don’t mean meditating or Mozart. I personally used a continuous-delivery local anesthetic system after abdominal surgery, and it was great. I didn’t have to deal with the side effects I get from opiates (constipation, but more awfully, migraines). With that system in place, I just needed a single dose of fentanyl right after the surgery, and then Tylenol.
Anyway, to answer the OP, No.