A military team will respond to future US ebola cases. This a major over reaction?

Just what we need when we’re sick and terrified that we might die. :dubious: A bunch of jack booted dudes in Camo and hazmat suits. Just the sight of those guys rushing you would trigger a heart attack.

Anyone else get memories of those 1950’s sci fi movies? Soon as weird stuff starts happening the military rolls in and cordons off the town. Military law. Civilians rounded up. Happened in just about every Sci Fi B movie.

Maybe my imagination is a bit over active. But the wording of this article concerns me. What kind of powers will they have? Can they declare martial law? Cordon off towns? Even supersede state authority? Will the patient’s civilian doctors even be consulted.

Shit, first the gov does practically nothing. Then they over react with a military strike force team? WTH is going on? This is our gov’s idea of leadership?

WHY NOT A CIVILIAN TEAM OF MEDICAL EXPERTS?

Is the second “military” in the title supposed to say “ebola”? Because the military responding to military cases sounds about right to me.

:smack: Thank you for the heads up. I’ll ask the mods to fix the thread title.

They make HAZMAT suits in camo now?

They are on order right now. :wink: **Everything **the military uses and wears is camo green. Except the combat boots which are spit shined black.

I changed the title as you asked.

Thank you Idle Thoughts. :wink:

It’s an over-reaction, all right.

Considering how bad the officials here in Dallas have flubbed up this thing so far, I’d say this is the right thing to do.

The fact is, the majority of facilities across the states just don’t have the training needed to handle this sort of thing.

Give your outrage muscles some rest. It’s a team of 20 nurses, 5 doctors, and 5 trainers. Hardly jack-booted thugs.

Do you really believe that military health team won’t be supported by other military?

First there will be a command structure. Probably a Captain in charge and other officers. Enlisted men.

I grew up on Air Force bases. My dad was a Master Sergeant . He was made First Sergeant of a squadron when he came back from Nam. I’m familiar with the mindset and culture. I have tremendous respect for the military and the role they play in protecting US interests abroad.

I don’t think a military presence is required for a health care crises. There’s no reason a team of specialists can’t be assembled that can quickly respond to an outbreak. Local law enforcement can enforce quarantines. Theres no need to militarize a health care response. imho

Heck, the military isn’t exactly known for their Military doctors. Their hospitals use a lot of civilians. My mom worked as a nurse in the base hospital. The quality of doctors varied a lot. Some just couldn’t make it in private practice. Some were good. Especially treating combat injuries.

Sorry, I defer to your extensive knowledge gained as a military dependent.
Eta: I’m actually retired military, btw. I have some idea of how they work.

Well, USAMRIID does have experience doing research with Ebola and have a long history of appropriately use of exposure protection equipment.

Albeit one of the four known lab accident exposures was at the USAMRIID labs at Ft Detrick.

At this point it’s probably better to overreact than be accused of underreacting. Politically if nothing else. It’s also apparent US hospitals aren’t really prepared for an Ebola outbreak and I don’t really blame them. A dedicated quick response team that knows its shit is a good idea.

I’m certainly no expert and apologize for overstating. I haven’t served and only been an observer. AFAIK , typically the military likes their command and support structure. I think this operation will be bigger than than reported. Maybe a hundred total with all the support staff? Just a WAG.

Traditionally the US has not actively deployed troops within our own borders. I think it’s a wise decision to allow local law enforcement and Federal agents to police the country.

Certainly a quick reacting Ebola response team is needed. Designated hospitals need to be selected for specialized treatment. Let the CDC and other experts do their jobs. Light a fire under their butts until they do their jobs correctly.

Military doctors are commissioned officers. The five doctors they chose will be O3s, at a minimum. Nurses are either O1s or O2s. The 5 trainers, who knows. In other words, the structure is built in.

Another aspect is logistics. One thing that the military is good at is getting folks and equipment from point A to point B within 72 hours, particularly when the people and equipment are already staged.

First, I don’t think there is a team of medical experts on the civillian side.

By that, I mean answering to one set of leadership, and can move a group of individuals anywhere in the country, and bring along a combat surgical hospital if it calls for that. When these same folks from Fort Detrick can call in an airstrike, then I might get a little antzy.

Declan

It’s a disaster response. Militaries do it all the time. We are good at it.

Why a three day response time? That seems rather long.

72 hours is the outside limit.