A pitting for Paul_was_in_Saudi

Yeah, sorry. That was my bad.

I was debating whether or not to make that explicitly clear and opted instead to take the blame if anybody got confused, which happened almost immediately.

100% my bad

No, I posted it because it was an Abe Lincoln story I had never heard of before. What is this “bullshit slur?”

Already explained and you “forgot” to answer my other question.

Is this your second question? It is obviously framed as a question but does not seem to be an attempt to gain information. Which ani-trans comments?

What a great question. Here’s an answer:

Fuck off. No one is playing your stupid game.

You graduated Harvard Law? I’m impressed.

You’re clearly not discussing in good faith and also making even more of an ass out of yourself that you already have over the years. I have had controversial views over the years, not despicable like yours of course, and I would be happy to discuss them. I at least have the character and courage to own them.

I have no idea which opinions I have that you find so offensive. When I ask you, you will not tell me.

So that is ofensive how? I am supportive of people being able to change their sex or their race.

I’m just going to quote this so we have it for posterity, in case he thinks better and edits it.

So you find it offensive that I can see a similarity between the freedom to choose your gender or (and) your race. Why does that offend you?

OK, what is offensive about discussing this group’s name change and its efficacy?

You’ve demonstrated that you have no clue on this topic, and even worse have no interest in learning. So I will decline to explain something to you that requires human decency and a room-temperature IQ to understand. Instead, I’ll just say fuck off.

I see you have me in the iron jaws of your superior intellect. I am simply devastated.

Yeah, equating transgender identity with “transracial identity” is kind of transphobic in and of itself.

Assigned sex (and corresponding gender category) is fundamentally about individual physical characteristics. Obstetricians look at an infant’s genitalia and decide “Boy” or “Girl”. So when transgender individuals decide that that birth assignment was wrong for them, and their gender is actually different, they are making a choice and a decision about nothing but their own bodies and identities.

But racial identity is not assigned to people fundamentally on the basis of their own physical characteristics, but rather on the basis of a group identity surrounding them. Obstetricians don’t put a color card against an infant’s skin and assign “White” or “Black” or “Brown” etc. There are plenty of racially white people who have darker complexions than some racially Black people, for example. Babies get assigned a racial identity based on the racial identity of their immediate family, particularly parents.

Race is thus not a solely individual characteristic like sex/gender, but derived from a group identity. That’s why it’s a very different thing for somebody assigned male at birth, for instance, to declare “Actually I identify as a woman”, versus somebody with a white racial identity declaring “Actually I identify as Black”. The former of those statements is changing a narrative only about the individual in question. The latter is claiming to change it about an associated group of people as well.

So you sort of figure The Group can impose a racial identity on a person, but not a gender identity? Wouldn’t it be easier to let people decide what they want to be?

I am fixing to go to bed. Please feel free to scream while I am gone. It might help you feel better.

I’m not angry. To the extent I get angry at all here (really annoyed) is when I butt heads with posters that I generally respect which is nearly everyone. I have no respect for you because you are pathetic. You have a sub mediocre mind and not even close to as clever as you imagine yourself to be. You’re a loser and you have wasted your life. I honestly feel sorry for you.