A question for dopers who have been hypnotized.

I was thinking about a hypnotist “performance” I saw a while back. You know the deal, a group of volunteers are hypnotized and then are made to do ridiculous and embarassing things.

If you’ve ever been one of the people hypnotized, what does it feel like? Are you fully aware of what’s going on? What goes through your mind when the hypnotist suggests that your fellow volunters are naked, etc. Do you actually “see” them naked or are you just pretending?

I’m really interested in post-hypnotic suggestions as well and what goes through your mind.

Please… responses from those who have experienced this first hand only. (no “I heard that…” please)

Thank you.

I was brought on stage by a hypnotist visiting my school a couple years ago. He started with a group of about 12, but whittled it down to about 7-8 because apparently some people do not take to the suggestions too well. I was allowed to stay on stage, but do not think I was “completely under.” Although a couple of the hypnotist’s suggestions worked (e.g., I smelled the things he said I should), nearly everything else didn’t work with me – which he works into his show, since he gave the wackiest tasks to those who were very open to suggestion (pretending they were Bruce Lee, making people think others were saying rude things to them, pretending to be a Martian, etc.).

As for your questions: I was completely aware of what was going on, and remember it all. After the performance, there were times when I clearly remember thinking to myself “I can choose whether I want to do this or not,” but ended up doing what he asked anyway. I’d be curious to hear from people who’ve been “more” hypnotized than I was.

Before I was hypnotized, my therapist described about four levels of hypnosis. He only took me to the first level, which is merely a state of deep relaxation where you can concentrate on the therapist’s words. He told me I wouldn’t have to be nervous about driving any more (I have serious highway anxiety when I am not on the road; being on the road is no big thing but when I’m trying to go to sleep I’ll often vividly imagine terrible car accidents I could have been in). I remember the whole thing in pretty good detail. It was very relaxing; afterwards all my muscles felt good and I felt more able to pay attention to details.

The other three levels of hypnosis sound more like the TV shows, where you can be convinced to do goofy things. I think these are used less commonly.

I was hypnotized once. It was the weirdest experience of my life, and I loved it.
Thankfully, our hypnotist didn’t ask us to do anything too embarassing.
Well, he brought us into deep relaxation. When he snapped and said ‘sleep’, I would close my eyes and go limp. I wasn’t really asleep. And I could open my eyes, and look around. In fact, the guy said that was normal under hypnotism.
He would plant a suggestion, and I knew I didn’t have to do what he said, but I did anyway.
Why? I can’t say, I just did.
Weird.

Hypnotism is a form of placebo response. You believe that hypnosis will unlock your inhibitions, so you allow yourself to do things that you might ordinarily not. There’s no magic, no “hypnotic state of mind” other than what you, the hypnotized, chose to create. You believe what you want to believe; feel what you want to feel; remember what you want to remember. The hypnotist has no power - he’s merely the proverbial “sugar pill”.

Here’s a thread where I answered another hypnosis question:
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?threadid=40760

First of all, the hypnosis you see on TV or in any other entertainment-type atmosphere is going to be just that-- entertaining. Most hypnosis is less exciting than that, and for the simple reason that the purpose of hypnosis is relaxation. In acts where people do funny things “under hypnosis”, I honestly doubt they truly are hypnotized. Given that they’re on stage, with hundreds of pairs of eyes and lots of cameras on them, I think it’s very likely that they’re just cooperating with the instructions of the “hypnotizer” so as not to look (more) stupid.

I have been hypnotized about four times now, each time lasting a short five to ten minutes. Ideally, they should last at least about twenty minutes, even longer if possible. I, along with my fellow psychology tutors, was hypnotized by a professor. What basically happens is that the hypnotizer talks the person into an extremely relaxed state. How well the person is relaxed in this manner depends on both the willingness of the hypnotizee to be led, and the ability of the hypnotizer to provide the suggestion. How well the person is hypnotized at all, for that matter, depends on the same interaction.

Once relaxed, you may be asked to visualize scenes. You may be asked to “interact” with these scenes. (This is the extent of my experience with hypnosis, and though it sounds limited, it’s really everything. You’ve heard of people asked to pretend they were chickens, or Elvis. It’s the same thing. You’re basically envisioning a scenario and acting appropriately.)

It’s important to note that the relationship between the hypnotizer and the hypnotizee is an active process. The hypnotizer provides the suggestions; the hypnotizee provides the follow-up to these suggestions. Contrary the idea that only one of them has any “power” over the other, what it really is is a partnership.

As a hypnotizee, you are fully aware of what’s going on. You know that you’re hypnotized. You know what you’re being asked to do. Although you may be asked to visualize being somewhere else or someone else, at some basic level you’ll always know who you are, where you are, and what you’re doing.

What goes through your mind when you’re given a suggestion (“Picture your hypnotizer naked!”) depends on the details of the suggestion given. If the hypnotizer says “Imagine me naked. I’ve got a nice, tanned body, and I exercise regularly. You really like how my body looks”, then you’ll probably follow the suggestion, and be turned on by his body. I say “probably” because of a second factor-- what runs through your mind will also depend on how deeply you are hypnotized. If you had reservations about the hypnosis, or resisted being totally relaxed, then you won’t totally follow the suggestion. You might think to yourself “But I really prefer pale, flabby bodies!” If you’re that detached from the procedure, then you chances are you will begin to pretend you’re into it.

It’s important to distinguish between following suggestions and pretending. They sound the same. In hypnosis, when you follow a suggestion, you are doing so willingly. You’re into it. You don’t notice the passage of time (as much). When you’re just pretending to be hypnotized, the session seems to drag on, and you have great difficulty cooperating what you’re asked to visualize and do. In fact, the whole thing will feel forced.

Post-hypnotic suggestion is pretty interesting stuff. It typically goes like this: While hypnotized, a person will be told “In a few seconds, I will bring you out of your hypnotized state. We will then continue our discussion on cold fusion. However, at one point during the lecture, I may say the word “light”. If you hear me say the word “light”, I want you to stand up from your desk, walk over to the lightswitch near the door, turn off the light, and say, ‘Gosh, it’s cold in here!’.” The person is then brought out of the hypnotized state. After recovering from the session (concentration’s tough after being relaxed for so long), the group conversation begins. The fun starts when the hypnotizer says “light”. I don’t have numbers or cites, but it has happened that the person has actually gotten up out of their seat and turned off the light and said it was cold.

Why it works is unknown, but it’s given weight to the divided consciouness theory of hypnosis, which is basically that when you’re hypnotized, your cognizant mind is on the shelf and your subconsciousness is on duty. When you’re brought out of hypnosis, your cognizant mind takes over, but the suggestions the subconscious side received will still spring into action if triggered.

I’ll end this way-too-long post by adding that not everyone is hypnotizable. Some people are more suggestible than others. (Though “suggestible” sounds like another way of saying “gullible”, it’s not, it’s different.) Some people have mental blocks against being hypnotized. Hypnotists have tests that can weed out these highly suggestible and stubbornly resistant folks.

Basically reiterating what others have said. I was hypnotized last year at a company meeting, as part of a dinner show. I remember everything the hypnotist said, and remember the things I did. Although I didn’t make a complete fool of myself, I did dance on stage (something I’m not comfortable doing, since I’m a terrible dancer), pretended to play the drums, and got into an “argument” with the hypnotist regarding the validity of hypnotism. I knew I was performing, and I knew I was on a stage; it just didn’t seem to matter much that 300 other people were in the room.

However, one of the other victims was well and truly out of it. We were told to relax in between our little performances, and this guy slumped in his chair so much that his knuckles touched the ground. He remembered absolutely nothing about the performance, and was by far the most suggestible of our little group.