Balthisar I have no wish to increase the number of abortions, I was merely wondering if the statistics take into account women who travel to other states or not. For example if the premise of the new law was"South Dakota Women don’t want abortions and don’t have abortions" based on theses statistics, but it could be shown that a significant number of South Dakota women were travelling elsewhere and that their existence was being “hidden” by falsely attributing their state of origin to the state where they had the abortion, it might matter a lot.
Part of the problem with the abortion situation in Ireland (which has abortion only for life of the mother cases) is that there is no reliable statistic on how many Irish women actually travel to the UK to have legal abortions. Which means that no-one has any real idea of how big an issue it is.
A figure of 11 Irish women a day is often quoted, this is based on the number of women who give Irish addresses to UK abortion clinics.
Some people argue many more Irish women travel and give bogus UK addresses, or the address of British relatives or their hotel. Others (mostly pro-life, it has to be said) argue that the numbers are greatly over-estimated because British women are giving bogus Irish addresses in a gesture of pro-choice solidarity with their Irish Sisters, which strikes me as much less likely!
I was wondering if the statistics were higher for neighbouring states, out of proportion to the numbers of women that could be reasonably expected, and which could be accounted for by South Dakota women. It would appear not, but that was why I asked.
I get that we’re talking massive distances and poorly populated rural areas, but surely nowhere is more than 2 days drive or an hour or two’s flight from a state border, and a desperate woman might not let a long bus or car trip or a short flight stand in her way.
I worked in the base hospital Broken Hill is NSW, which is 500km from Adelaide and 1200km from Sydney. Although the OB/GYN service at Broken Hill would perform abortions, they rarely had to, as most local women preferred to travel the 14 hours to Sydney or the 7 hours to Adelaide, where the chance of gossip getting back to Broken Hill was much slimmer. If you’ve ever been to Broken Hill you’ll know that gossip is the local oxygen, so their concerns were not entirely without foundation.