Actors You Love To Hate

Okay, so we have threads about actors you love and threads about actors you hate, but what about actors that somehow fall into both categories?

I hate Rene Zellwiger (sp) but she keeps making fantastic movies! Whenever I think about her my mind conjures up pictures of Skeletor but I am somehow drawn to the movies she makes. I think maybe she and I just have similar taste in literature/cinema and it isn’t her I want to see but the movie itself.

So who do you pay money to see in the theater even though you dispise them?

I had the same thing with Steve Martin. I disliked his comedy act, but I found I ended up seeing his movies and liking them. Finally, I began to appreciate his acting.

He was terrible at standup, though.

Angelina Jolie. I don’t know that I’ve ever actually seen her act, but she sure ends up in movies I want to see.

I’m not a big Angelina fan myself but I don’t have any particular problem with her. She just isn’t my favorite. Her dad is one of those uber-creepy people I can’t stand to see in movies though. He freaks me out.

Every time I see Leo DiCaprio in a non-acting capacity I just want to smash his smug little face in – which is quite an extreme reaction for someone who ordinarily wouldn’t hurt a fly.

But damn, no matter how badly I want to say he’s a terrible actor, I can’t. The kid is damned good. The last few movies I saw him in were all exceptional.

I have a similar reaction to DiCaprio. The only film I’ve seen him is was Catch Me if You Can, and he was surprisingly good :smack:

Liv Tyler and Keira Knightley drive me insane.

Thirded on DiCaprio. Shit. I want to hate him, but he’s damn good, and he’s in damn good movies. Makes me hate him more. I’m not hurting anyone but myself, but I enjoy it. :smiley:

Tom Cruise and I have remarkably similar tastes in movies, since I end up loving just about everything he’s in. But where as before my opinion of him was more or less “meh,” it’s turned into outright dislike. But I still love his movies.

I adore DiCaprio. I don’t think he’s good-looking, but he is easily one of the best actors of my generation.

As I watched Titanic on t.v. the other night I was struck by a tangible hatred for Frances Fisher. She almost always plays an unsympathetic or downright bitchy part, and damn if she doesn’t always get me to fall for it. I also find her looks quite unappealing yet compelling at the same time. So while these factors add up to a certain dislike for her, I do think she’s a wonderful actress.

Lucky for me, I only like Cruise in about half of what he does. Which means I can still hate his guts.

Second the OP on Renee Zellwegger, whose squinty looks drive me batshit – I’ve seen more of her movies than I care to contemplate, though (most recently Miss Potter).

Not an actor per se, but Justin Timberlake is just awful.
Proof? Edison Force (or something like that).

Michael Douglas absolutely makes my skin crawl. Always has, long before he married Katherine whatsherface. Most of the time, I’ll make a conscious effort to avoid a movie if I see his name in the credits, but a few years ago I was intrigued by the trailer for Wonder Boys. And ya know what, for a couple of hours there, he made me forget that most of the time, the mere sight of him makes me want to go take a shower!

Peter MacNicol on 24
Gregory Itzin on 24