Adopting a Dog: Dopers' Experiences?

Another vote for rescue organizations. I’ve rescued three dogs this way. Generally, if they were in the pound or something and have issues, the rescue groups will put them in foster homes for a while. This way, they often get housebroken, crate-trained, and maybe even given a little obedience training. The added bonus is you often get a chance to talk to the foster and find out exactly what the dog’s issues are.

I recently adopted a pitbull/bulldog mix from a rescue org. Obligatory pic: The Lady Miss Harriet. She had been on death row at a dog pound and was scheduled for death the day the rescue group pulled her. She was fostered for 3-4 months, so by the time I got her:

•She had been spayed
• She had been de-wormed, and mites/mange dealt with and healed. (in fact, she had every bug a dog could have and the rescue group paid for all that treatment, not me – another bonus to rescue groups)
•It was clear she had no skin issues, allergies, or other medical problems.
•She was crate-trained and housebroken.
•She already knew sit-stay, no-no-bad-dog, lay down, and come here.
• Also, she’d been fostered in a house that had a cat, so she was already on friendly terms with cats and has never tried to eat mine. Well, she tries, but she gets her butt whooped by the cat, who is 1/5 her size.

Also, I was able to meet with the foster “mom” several times to find out about Harriet’s little behavior quirks and habits. I found out that she’ll do anything for a peanut-butter-smeared Kong treat and that she likes to go outside to pee in the morning, but then will come inside for her breakfast, but she likes to go out again after breakfast for poopies. This was extremely useful information to have the first week. Shelters and dog pounds don’t know anything about the dog’s personality or medical history, so it’s more of a crapshoot.

Yes, rescues and shelters can be picky. When you walk out with a dog, they never want to see it again. They want to it to be a successful placement. My son adopted a dog from a shelter a few years ago. He had to bring a note from his landlord.

From my hoard of dog lore:

Consider the animal shelter. There are many nice dogs, and you can see how they look with little or no grooming. You can also see how they behave. Look for dogs that want your attention, but are not going wild. Leave the ones that retreat to the back of their cage. Look at their teeth. Look for ones that still show a 3 lobed, clove like pattern on the front ones. Leave the ones that fight letting you look at their teeth too much. If the points are worn off the teeth, it is an older dog that may break your heart by dying too soon. Pinch the web between its toes. It hurts. It is OK for the dog to pull away or whine, but it shouldn’t growl, snap or show its teeth. Think about size. In a small apartment, a Golden might knock over the lamps when it walks through wagging its tail. Since the shelter likely will kill most of the dogs, you may as well pick out a nice one.

A large study by (HSUS? ASPCA?) several years ago questioned on why people [del] dumped [/del] gave up dogs. Contrary to popular opinion, the reasons were rarely because of anything wrong with the dog. Mostly it was things like, moving, can’t keep; can’t afford; allergies; landlord won’t allow it, and so on. Even if it’s a behavioural issue, it’s usually something fairly easy to fix - but too many people lack commitment to a pet.

Anyhow, I’ve worked in rescue and fostered dogs on and off for about 20 years, and most of the dogs I’ve owned are from shelters, rescues or were “failed fosters.” (Foster dogs I ended up keeping, like my black Lab.) Quite a few were in the shelter because they were seized from neglectful or abusive situations. Or were let loose or dumped by people who didn’t want them. Or for some reason, weren’t attractive enough to catch the eye of potential adopters at a busy kill shelter and were passed over - but still very awesome family dogs. I’ve also fostered several blind dogs for a nationwide blind dog rescue.

Going through a breed rescue, or any rescue that houses dogs in foster homes is a really good way to get more of a known entity. I am picky about letting “my” foster dogs go, absolutely - I want it to be a good fit, and since a foster home has cared for, trained, and gotten to know the dog in question, we are typically quite protective of it! Also I will know how the dog is with other dogs, cats, kids, people…what it knows and what it still needs to learn, its activity level, and so on.

Also, being a foster home is a GREAT idea. :slight_smile:

I would warn against doing those things to a dog you don’t know without being trained on how to properly assess a dog’s temperament.

I’ve met my share of veterinarians who are clueless about the specific health problems of the breed you’re into, and what constitutes ethical breeding practices. Contact your city or state’s breed club (e.g., The German Shepherd Club of Western Dakota or, The GSD Club of Gotham City) and ask for the names of vets who are experienced in the breed. You can also ask a rescue group which vet they use.

One ethical and respected breeder’s experience, posted recently on a dog-related board:

"I need help in {city}, PLEASE! I have a couple of our pups placed there whose owners are in need of quality vet care. I am shocked at the things I am hearing from the vets they are currently using.

One puppy owner was told that they must do the puppies’ hips by 6 months of age or it will be too late to fix them if anything is wrong, WTF??? Both parents OFA excellent, btw.

Another puppy has had demodex, warts, and now what they say are seromas? If this puppy has seromas this big and this often, then someone is hitting that dog and I need to know! These sound like immune or stress issues to me and if the puppy has an issue, I need to know.

They also told the owner the puppy is vWD borderline because they ran the Elisa on him. He is vWD clear by Vetgen!

I am so upset and really need to know what’s up from a vet I can trust too.

So please, recommendations for a vet in {city} who knows {breed}, or at least knows what the heck they are doing?"
Adoption fees vary depending on how much funding the agency receives. Some public animal control facilities are funded (e.g., through taxes, user fees, donations) to subsidize vaccinations and neutering. Some ACFs, regardless of size, cannot afford having a vet on staff, so the cost of treating the animal falls to the purchaser. There are all sorts of funding scenarios in between these situations.

Private animal shelters are funded through a mix of adoption fees, donations of cash or supplies, sales of donated pet supplies, one-time grants from private foundations, grants from the city/county, donation of time by vets, vet techs and kennel helpers. Some receive funding from all these sources, some struggle every day just to be able to afford food for their animals.

Rescue groups are funded though adoption fees, donations, reduced fees by vets, and having foster parents pay for the animals’ feed, toys, deworming meds, bedding, winter coats, etc. Their adoption fees tend to be higher because they don’t receive the level of funding that public ACFs and private animal shelters do.

Example #1a: my local municipal ACF can afford to release dogs and cats without charge to 501©(3) rescue groups. Before they’re released, the dogs are altered, microchipped, tested for heartworms using both the DNA and smear tests, and vaccinated against rabies, DHLPP and bordetella. They are not funded to treat heartworm-positive dogs.
Example #1b: my local municipal ACF’s adoption fee to the general public is less than $90 for dogs, and the fee is waived if the dog is heartworm-positive.

Example #2: my current foster dog came from a county ACF that isn’t funded for vet care. On his first vet visit he was altered, microchipped, tested for heartworms and internal parasites (and given a broad spectrum dewormer), vaccinated against rabies, DHLPP and bordetella, had his thyroid functioning tested and some other services.

The vet bill, even with the “rescue rate” discount, was over $360. His adoption fee is $250. Who covers the difference? The members of the private rescue group. How do we pay for it? Out of our personal funds. (Some people choose to buy fancy cars, TVs, boats, or dine out at five-star restaurants. We choose to buy vet treatment for abandoned dogs.)

And it’s a good thing my foster dog doesn’t have heartworms, because the one vet clinic in this county that offered low-cost heartworm treatment (funded through donations and grants) stopped doing it because Merial stopped production on Immiticide due to manufacturing problems. So, we have to take heartworm-positive dogs to private vet clinics. Even with a “rescue rate”, treating a dog the size of my foster dog would run at least $700. There is no way an adopter will pay $950 for a dog, so the members of the rescue group cover the cost out of our personal funds.

Some dogs are in such poor condition when they are rescued, their bet bills run into the thousands of dollars. These dogs often take a long time to recover physically and then they need to be housetrained, obedience trained, crate trained, etc. In other words, turned into desirable companions. After a foster parent has made the time and emotional investment in a dog’s recovery and rehabilitation, they want to ensure whoever adopts it will take as good–or better–care of it than they did. Thus the “interrogation” of potential adopters.

Physically handling a dog at an ACF/animal shelter: unless you are experienced at reading canine body language, I do not recommend handling an unknown dog’s mouth or paws. Bear in mind that some dogs were injured before they arrived at the facility. A dog with rotten teeth or burrs embedded in its paw will not take kindly to having its mouth or feet handled by a stranger.

Just a few observations based on my experience. Hope this helps explain why private rescue groups operate the way they do.

We got our dog from a private shelter. We asked for a cat-safe dog who was house broken and laid back. They gave us a cat safe dog who was house broken and laid back… and is neurotic and afraid of the rain, but that’s okay, we still like him. :slight_smile: In my experience, a well run shelter knows their dogs. They want to give you a dog that works for you because they don’t want you to bring him back.

I would absolutely NEVER get a puppy again, after getting an adult dog. (Previously, I’d gotten dogs as puppies.) It’s already housebroken! Captain actually came half trained, too - he does this huge theatrical “down” where he slaps the ground with his paws. It’s adorable.

I work at a shelter and it’s a fact that dogs are put there for a million different reasons-- and it’s very rarely the dog’s fault. Please consider a shelter pet: it’s inexpensive, very rewarding, and you may be saving the animal’s life.

We adopted a 2 year old poodle mix from a local shelter and it worked out well. She had been transported several hundred miles from a shelter in Missouri, so the local shelter did not have much info about her history. Our suspicion is that she may have been a puppy mill dog, based on how she behaved when we first got her (and the fact that Missouri is notorious for puppy mills). When we got her, she was completely untrained and didn’t seem to be familiar with many normal household things.
We did have to train her, of course, but training is a must with any dog. I feel that the vast majority of dogs, even those with “issues”, can be worked with if the human is willing to take the time and learn how to work with the dog. It’s my opinion that most of the time when people give up their dogs to shelters it’s because the owner was unable or unwilling to work with the dog, not the dog’s fault. There are far many more bad owners out there than bad dogs.
I think that adopting adult dogs is a great idea. Too many people don’t even give adult homeless animals a chance, even when the animal is young enough to still have a long life ahead of it if someone takes it home. With an adult dog you pretty much are getting what you see, rather then unknowns that come with getting a puppy.

This won’t help you with your desire for a German Shepherd but we are thrilled with our greyhounds, another way to go with “repurposed” dogs, most of whom are only 3 to 4 years old. There are many organizations that work to place these “retired” racers. This is the one we adopted from (and currently are members of), but there are many others. Sweet animals. The dogs come to their new homes spayed/neutered, microchipped, heart worm checked, with teeth cleaned. They’ve been fostered first to get them more new home ready and our organization requires that families with non-adult children attend a seminar to help make sure that the family is ready for the dog.

This was my experience also. Went to the local shelter, and all the dogs were barking their heads off, except for one black lab mix who sat calmly in the front of the cage. Took her for a walk, went to lunch and went back and got her. My husband and I have had dogs all our lives, and agree that she is THE cutest, sweetest, lovingest dog we have ever had.NO bad habits whatsoever…doesn’t bark unless someone comes to the door,etc…My recommendation is to head to a shelter to get a dog…they are forever grateful!!! :slight_smile: