Adoption Agencies: A Cautionary Tale (very long)

This isn’t mundane or pointless, at least to me, but I don’t have the energy required for Pit-worthy vitriol.

Mr. Stuff and I have wanted to be parents since we got married. Nearly a year ago, we decided to pursue adoption. We heard about a local agency, got four references from people we know that had used them, and checked them out using a free service in Indiana that tries to help people adopt. We didn’t hear anything to put us off, so we signed on. After jumping through all the necessary hoops – not an inconsiderable feat in itself – we were ready to meet birthmoms. The second birthmom who looked at us chose us. We were thrilled. She was due in three months. Long story short, gory details omitted, that fell through. Well, it happens. We grieved, but moved on.

Not too much later, we were chosen again! Hooray! This time, the birthmom and her family wanted us to be at the birth. We were. Totally amazing. We saw this boy take his first breath. We fell in love with him immediately. Then, two days later, the birthmom changed her mind. We were devastated, as you might imagine. Three days after that, the agency called us. Miracle of miracles, the birthmom changed her mind again, and had signed off on the adoption. We were ecstatic. We brought the baby home. What joy! What happiness! We love the little piker so much it aches. As part of our open adoption agreement, we see the birthmom and her family occasionally. They can see how much we love our son, and seem to genuinely like us. We genuinely like them. We are finally mommy and daddy, and we love it.

Fast forward two months. We are informed by the adoption agency that our son’s birthfather is suing for full custody, but not to worry. They’ve had to fight birthfathers before, and they’ve never lost. They have super duper lawyers. Able to leap tall buildings in a single bound. Unfortunately, it seems that their super duper lawyers never faced any real opposition. The first hearing scheduled in the case went horribly wrong (from our point of view, of course), and the super duper lawyers basically turned tail and ran. Called us once to tell us about the hearing. Never heard from them again. Couldn’t get any return phone calls – much less answers – out of anyone at the agency. Later, we were told that they couldn’t contact us because of the legal nature of the case; they were depending on the lawyers to keep us informed. If you’re going to depend on lawyers, you should get some flipping dependable lawyers. But I digress.

At this point, we begin to talk extensively to the birthmother’s family about the situation with the birthfather (let me point out that the agency previously encouraged us not to talk about it too much out of “sensitivity to the birthmother’s feelings”), and we find out that the birthfather has been opposing the adoption vociferously from before the baby was born, and the agency never told us this. Yes, they informed us (and made us sign forms saying they had informed us) that there is always risk, and that the birthfather in this case wasn’t signing off. But they continually assured us that they knew what they were doing, and played down the risk to a great degree. (Remember, we have super duper lawyers!!) Basically we were grossly misled.

We aren’t actually angry at the birthfather – he was stonewalled from the beginning, and he needed to be heard. We are, however, angry at the agency, who should never have placed this baby in our home, given the situation with the birthfather. I know adoption is a money game, but it’s people’s lives you’re playing with. Have an ounce of compassion. Please.

So, what all this boils down to is this: the little boy that we love, that we cared for day and night for two months, who will always be our son no matter what the law says, is gone. We miss him so badly that sometimes it’s difficult to breathe.

There are, of course, a bunch of details and complexities left out of this, but it’s long enough already. This whole fiasco has been so painful that I can’t imagine where I’ll find the courage ever to try to adopt again. I don’t know if that feeling will last, but for now, I want to run around and warn everyone I know that’s thinking of adopting. Which is a lot of people, as it happens. I’m not, of course. I’m keeping my mouth shut like a good girl.

If anyone is out there that has experienced this, I sure would appreciate a few words telling me how you made it out the other side. Today, I feel like I’ll never be happy again.

In the category of “And the Hits Just Keep On Coming,” last night our dog was hit and killed on the road. She’s just a dog, but it’s still depressing. On the other hand, as I sit here and think about everything, I realize that I would gladly have shot the dog in cold blood if it would bring back our baby boy. While I can’t speak for anyone else, it definitively proves that I, at least, will never love a pet as much as a child.

That is such a tragic story. I’m sorry for what you and your husband are going through. :frowning:

Wow, I am so sorry. That is heartbreaking.

Just wondering, does the birthfather have full custody of the baby now? If so what is their situation (how does the single father care for him?) If not, who is the baby with now?

Legally speaking, does a birth father have 100% “veto power” over an adoption? That is, if the birthmom wants to give the baby up, is he required to agree to it (as in, legally sign away parental right), or take full custody?

In your case it sounds like it was known the birthfather objected to the adoption, but yet you and the agency went forth with the adoption anyway (although you didn’t know the full extent of his objection). Was that because although he objected, he would have to be willing to take full custody in order to stop the adoption?

No. The birthmother’s mother has temporary custody, until things are sorted out. The birthmother and birthfather are 14 and 15, respectively. The baby is primarily with the birthmother and her family, although the birthfather has visitation. The birthfather is currently seeking only visitation, not full custody, as far as we know. It is our fond hope that the birthmother will retain custody. While just as young, she has a much more stable family situation. Minor things like, oh, say … no registered sex offenders in the immediate family, which the birthfather has.

Sort of. If the birthfather is involved, he must legally sign. However, the birthfather is not involved in 75% of adoption cases, or so we were told by the agency (whose word we now have occasion to question). In those cases, in Ohio, the birthfather has 31 days after the birth of the baby to sign up in what’s called the putative father registry. If he doesn’t sign up within those 31 days, he loses parental rights. So, at least sometimes, the birthfather is not a factor.

BTW, IANALawyer, and any legal-speak in this thread is a lay person’s pitiful understanding.

Yes, we did go forth. In the case of Mr. Stuff and I, it was blindly and under bad advice. I’m not sure how we could have understood the problem with the information that we had, to be honest. We were told, after the birth of the baby, that the birthfather had not registered in the putative father registry mentioned above, and in the opinion of the agency, was unlikely to do so. This was incorrect, as he had done so before the birth. Had we known that, we never would have gone forward. We don’t know whether the agency outright lied or whether they are incompetent lumbering idiots. They SAY that they check the putative registry every day to keep up. If this is true, they lied to us. And to the birthmother and her family, which is maybe worse yet.

We were also told that even if he did register, it didn’t matter because he couldn’t prove support to the birthmother during the pregnancy. Our current, and competent, attorney informs us that this is just so much crap. I wish we had met our current attorney before this all started.

I really am troubled, trying to figure out what we could have done differently. I know we took a risk, but most adoptions involve some risk. This one was presented to us as really not more risky than others, so we went ahead. I don’t know whether to wish we hadn’t or not. If we hadn’t, our hearts wouldn’t be broken. But we also would never have known our baby boy, and I’m not completely sure it wasn’t worth it. I can’t find the quote anymore, but Peter King said once that “The only way to keep from hurting so much is to never love anything so much, and that is surely no way to live.”

… love anyone so much.

Grr.

What if the bio-father didn’t know the birthmother was pregnant or she told him she got an abortion? What if he doesn’t find until after the 31 day window is up?

Truly? I don’t know. I know that’s not a satisfying answer, but it’s the only one I’ve got.

A *15 year old * was opposing the adoption of the baby of his 14 year old girlfriend. That’s unusual to say the least.

Um. Wow. That’s unspeakably horrible. But if the birthfather is just trying to get visitation now, wouldn’t it be possible for you and your husband to work that out with him? Or is the birth mother re-re-re-considering now?

I’m very, very sorry this is happening to your family.

Our lawyer is working on that very thing, actually. He’s presenting all parties (attorneys for both birthparents as well as a guardian ad litem for the baby) with an open adoption plan, in which both birthparents get visitation rights. I am, frankly, not holding out a lot of hope, because the birthfather and his family don’t seem like people that can be talked to much. Our lawyer is trying, though. We believe that he’ll tell us when it’s time to completely throw in the towel, and he hasn’t said that yet.

The birthmother and her family are still very much in support of the adoption, despite the fact that the baby has been living with them. I know they love him, and I’m sure they’re growing more and more attached, but for now, they still want him to come back to us. It’s one of my fears, though, that we’ll work something out with the birthfather, and the birthmother will not be able to give the baby up again.

One way or another, it doesn’t look too good for us. But I don’t think we could live with ourselves if we didn’t at least try.

Well hell, just let the birthfather have the little tyke over a couple friday and saturday nights, so the 15 year old can get a sense of what he’s really asking for. If possible, see if his favorite band is coming to town soon and offer that weekend.

Those kids will never be able to provide as stable a home for that baby as you and the Mister can. Hell, they still have to get through high school.

Here’s hoping a judge finds in your favor. And quite frankly, if the birthfather is oppossing the adoption, he should get FULL CUSTODY, not visitation rights. If he wants the baby, he gets it, 2am feedings and colicky screaming and all.

Our lawyer and the boy’s lawyer recommended it, and it’s in the works. He’s had one overnight visit, and they’re trying to work something out where he’d keep the baby over a few school nights, so he’d have to do homework and bathe baby and feed baby and change baby and comfort baby when he screams through his fussy time and get up the middle of the night with baby and go to school sleep deprived and lather, rinse, repeat.

I certainly wasn’t selfless or mature enough at 15 to have liked it. I hope this kid’s mom actually makes him do it.

Thank you for saying so. It’s certainly what we think. We keep hoping and praying that the birthfather will somehow see through his teenage haze and think so, too.

Oh god, I am so so sorry.

What an awful situation. I’m wondering…would you have an option for using a surrogate? I think it would be so much better because she’s doing it specifically to help couples such as yourself. Is this something an agency can set you up for?

Based on the description of the situation I really, really doubt the 15 year old is personally driving the resistance to the adoption. I’d hazard a guess that his mother or grandmother is behind the push to resist adoption in this situation.

It’s not something we’ve considered. I don’t know what we’ll consider in the future. We need to figure out what’s going on with this situation, for sure. Then we need to heal (if it goes badly) and get our heads on straight. We know that we want to be parents, and we’ll have to figure out how to make that happen.

There is some of that, or a lot of that. We are hearing almost everything second, third, and fourth hand, so it’s difficult to determine exactly who is saying what. We do think that the boy’s stepmom is a factor, too.