OK, my MIL arrived, I have a moment now (yes, I’m veryveryvery lucky).
When I said “our kids don’t fit her mold,” I meant my husband’s and mine - I realize that was a little confusing. What I was trying to say is that I now have an almost five year old, and she was a terrible napper, and not a great sleeper. She wouldn’t nap for more than 40 minutes or so no matter what I did. I got really frustrated. Now I think that’s just the way she was put together, and she had to grow out of it. By the time she was ten months old, she was sleeping and napping very well. We did let her cry for a while when she was seven months old and decided she liked nighttime visits, and was getting up every 30 to 60 minutes all night.
I think you have to listen to your gut on the cry it out advice. If you are completely mental from sleep deprivation, you cannot be a good parent. And if CIO seems to work, and it doesn’t bother you too much, I guess it’s better than miserable zombie Mom! But if it gives you an ulcer to leave your baby to cry, like it does me, feel free to try other things. Also beware that CIO tends not to work for high needs babies - they cycle up and up and up instead. People who tell you they had miracles with CIO probably had babies of more average temperament. Anyway, there’s no law that says you must not lie down with your baby for naps, or that you can’t hold him. Whatever gives you the maximum combined sleep and peace of mind.
Oh, as for tummy sleeping, IIRC, 90% or more of SIDS cases occur between 2 and 6 months of age. Personally, I would feel comfortable removing one SIDS precaution around 6 months. Obviously, ask your doctor, but if you have the baby in your room, no one smokes around him, he has a safe firm mattress, no blankets or pillows, and so on, the risk might be very small. Of course, if he’s rolling, he might chose his tummy all on his own, and all the experts say not to worry about that.
Here is what’s working to keep us sane right now. Sometimes I hold Claire for naps, sometimes I put her down and resign myself that she will be up within 30 minutes. To get her to sleep, we give her a pacifier and either rock her or wear her, sometimes with patting as well. Standing up is often required.
At night, she gets a bath at the same time every night, then into her PJs, nurse, swaddle, and I hold her till she’s asleep. Then she sleeps in her Amby Baby hammock bed in our room. I get up with her when she wakes up, sometimes nursing sometimes just rocking/paci. Around 4-5 am when she gets up, I just take her into bed with me, since she has trouble getting back to sleep around then. If she’s been up a lot, and I’m really tired, I wake up my husband sometime between 4 and 6, and he takes her out of the bedroom while I get to sleep for 2-3 hours uninterrupted, which really makes all the difference. (And evidently you can play Team Fortress II with a baby strapped to you.)
If you would like some support, some "you poor thing!"s and some ideas that might help, I suggest checking out a La Leche League meeting. Sometimes it helps to just talk to other mothers, and the organization is not just about breastfeeding, but about supporting mothers. You can find a meeting here: http://groups.lllc.ca/groups.php?prov=ON