[QUOTE=Sean Factotum]
I found an interesting quote in the Washington Post article about Gary Trudeau (“Doonesbury”):
THE TYPICAL DAILY NEWSPAPER COMIC STRIP HAS A DEGENERATIVE ARC. The cartoonist’s best years come early, when the ideas are fresh, the gimmick is still a novelty and the grind of daily deadlines has not yet taken its toll on creativity. Three years of excellence is a pretty good run before the inevitable decline, as the cartoonist runs out of new things to say and becomes content to imitate himself. It’s easy to forget, but many of today’s formulaic, intellectually listless strips, such as “B.C.,” “Cathy” and “Dennis the Menace,” were once lively and daring and different. They’re still around because their bland familiarity becomes a sort of comfort food, and newspaper editors are loath to drop them.
[/QUOTE]
It’s an odd phenomenon.
As much as music, and TV shows (like SNL and The Simpsons), all comics are remembered more fondly in the past than in the present. You remember “ah, Dilbert used to be funny” when in reality, just like today, there was 1 or 2 strips every couple of weeks that made you laugh.
I think that if a “future man” were really able to look at a Dilbert from today, and a Dilbert from 10 years ago, he would find them equally amusing. The fact that WE have been reading Dilbert for 10-12 years makes it impossible to give it an unbiased critique.
So, I don’t really agree agree that quality declines with comics in general, but it’s impossible for the material to stay fresh.
I really respect the Berkely Breatheds and Wattersons and Larsons who can walk away from it.
It’s kind of sad because these people are artists/writers/comedians who just get pigeon holed by their own success. Even if they try to branch out, like Jim Davis with the barnyard strip, or Breathed with Outlands, they’re still damned by their previous accomplishments.
It seems to wear on Aaron Macgruder. He’s in repeats 2 or 3 times a year it seems.