I’m not sure if I have the terminology right, but what I mean is an album where every song that wasn’t released as a radio single is better than what was played on the radio. My offering for this is Men at Work’s ‘Business As Usual’. I really like listening to this, but only when I skip the three songs that hit the radio. (Well, I can enjoy ‘Be Good Johnny’, but you get the picture).
I just chimed in to say I quite enjoy the other two singles. and that your offering is pretty strong.
I guess any offering I have would be that Genesis’s eponymous album, or Peter Gabriel 3 and 4. But All I’m really saying is that they are strong albums, not that the singles are weak.
I was thinking about that (a strong album) also, and in that category I’ll mention ‘August and Everything After’ by the Counting Crows. As far as I’m concerned, every song on that is great.
On the Genesis/Peter Gabriel front, I got to add Selling England By The Pound. The one and only single from that, “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe)”, is most certainly a great and fun song in its own right, but I would dare say that the near entire album surrounding it is even better…ESPECIALLY “Dancing With The Moonlit Knight”, “Firth of Fifth”, and “The Battle of Epping Forest”.
Also have to nominate my two Steely Dan favorites in Countdown To Ecstasy (notably “Bodhisattva”, “Your Gold Teeth”, and “King of the World”…actually quite surprised these were never official singles at all) and “The Royal Scam” (particularly “Don’t Take Me Alive”, “Green Earrings”, and the title-track…also amazed that “Don’t Take Me Alive” never saw official single release).
Heh, the first thing I thought of was Genesis’s Invisible Touch album. It’s been quite a while since I’ve heard it, but I remember liking the non-single tracks, while all the singles except for “Land of Confusion” left me cold.
If you want to count unsuccessful singles, Spirit’s 12 Dreams of Doctor Sardonicus is one of the top ten albums of the 70s, though it’s single “Nature’s Way” – while of high quality – is not even close to being the best song on the album. It was released as the group was splitting up, so the record company didn’t care.
Traffic’s “Paper Sun” was a hit in the UK (their biggest hit anywhere), but when one thinks of the album it’s on, it’s usually for “Dear Mr. Fantasy,” and the album (Mr Fantasy has quite a few better songs on it.
Every Prince album is full of great material not released as a single. Some of my personal ‘non-single’ favorites :
“Life Can Be So Nice” - Parade
“It” “Hot Thing” - Sign O’ The Times
“Electric Chair” - Batman Soundtrack
“Thunder” - Diamonds & Pearls
“Dark” - Come
“P. Control” - The Gold Experience
Every song on that album got radio airplay, at the time, except for “Silver Rainbow.” So are you saying that is the best song on the album?
Although if we’re strictly talking songs released as singles…
…In this case, all but two out of eight songs (“Domino” and “The Brazillian”) got airplay, and I believe all six songs that were played on the radio were released as singles. Which still works fine for this thread, as “Domino” and “The Brazillian” happen to be the two best songs on the album.
We Were Dead Before The Ship Even Sank by Modest Mouse. While I wouldn’t say that the non-single tracks were a lot better, per se, than the single Dashboard, I’d say that Dashboard doesn’t add anything that hadn’t been said in either the Good News album or peppy indie songs by other artists. Their other tracks make more of a statement (and are slightly better IMO).
Well into nitpicking here, but I thought “Second Home by the Sea” didn’t (I guess rock stations might have played both so the DJ could piss) and “It’s Gonna Get Better” didn’t.
But I think I could say those three are better than the singles except maybe “Mama”
I do remember hearing “It’s Gonna Get Better.” I guess you’re right about “Second Home By the Sea,” though. I always think of both parts as a single song, so I wasn’t differentiating.
As for Invisible Touch, it looks like “Anything She Does” wasn’t released as a single. I remember hearing it on the radio, and they made a video for it, I wonder why they didn’t make it official…
Joan Osborne’s Relish had the hit “One of Us”, but rest of the album was much better with its simmering blues rock tunes.
Extreme’s Extreme II: Pornograffitti had two singles, “More Than Words” and “Hole Hearted” which sound almost nothing like the rest of the album, which is some great hard rock. The singles are not weak necessarily, just so completely different.
One of my favorite albums is Bonafide, by Jon B. There were three songs released as singles from that album: “Someone to Love,” “Pretty Girl” and “Isn’t it Scary.” They are, respectively, the fifth, eighth, and twelfth-best (of 13) songs on the album, IMO.
According to Wikipedia, Sheryl Crow’s Tuesday Night Music Club featured six songs that were released as singles: I liked two of them. The best song on the album IMO, “We Do What We Can,” was not released as a single.