I think Idols encourages them to say refer to their “fans”.
Tonight’s show
Fantasia: “Something About the Way You Look Tonight” A good song choice for her, she was good but Simon was right that she was screeching at parts. And I am hating her attitude more and more, if she doesn’t go soon, she at least deserves a “bottom 3” slap in the face.
Jon Peter: “Rocket Man” Ouch. I think he’s given up. He’s not even trying.
Jasmine: Oh no you di’ent! Dang girl sang “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me” and she didn’t pull it off. She was “pitchy” as Randy and Paula like to say, and she was just plain flat on at least one of the "me"s. When Clay did that song last year I would have offered to have his baby on the spot, I just wanted to slap her and rip that damn flower out of her hair and stomp it, stomp it good.
John S.: “Crocodile Rock” He sung an up-tempo song and moved around which was great to see him do. Unfortunately he had a little trouble with the "lalala"s and saying “crocodile” really fast. I don’t agree with Randy and Simon that it was the worst of the night - of course they hadn’t see Camille yet …
Camille: “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” Pitchy, thy name is Camille. Her voice was very shaky at the beginning, after that she was all over the place. I just hope Simon’s comments about it being the end of the road for her don’t win her even more sympathy votes. Please America put us out of her misery and let her go!
George: “Take me to the Pilot” Very good. It had a gospel feel to it but it worked well for him. I had my doubts about him in the beginning but he keeps getting better.
Hey, they cut Simon off even when he’s complimenting people.
Diana:“I’m Still Standing” Not her best. She seemed out of breath on the verses. Simon had nothing to say? What does that mean? Did he just give up on criticizing people?
LaToya: “Someone Saved My Life Tonight” -Elton said “the fact that she was in the bottom 3 last weeks shows there’s lots of idiots out there”. It wasn’t flawless but it was one of the best of the night. She had a little trouble with breath control on some of the slower verses, that seemed to be the problem many of the other performers had but it wasn’t as obvious with her.
Jennifer: “Circle of Life” - Good, but full of melisma and all that at least she pulled it off. Seemed a bit weak at the beginning. I found it amusing that the camera focused on her hand at one point, I wondered if that’s because they wanted to avoid her scary faces.
Bottom 3:
Camille
JPL
John S
Any of those three deserve to go, but please let it be Camille, she’s dodged the bullet long enough.
And no “Your Song”? I guess I should be greatful it wasn’t mangled.