Sigmagirl, I feel the same way reading this thread. Then I feel terrible for being petty and shallow and materialistic.
For our ten year anniversary I got him hand blown wine glasses that he loves (he likes his wine) and a surprise remodel of the living room including a new floor. I can still picture him walking in and just standing there with his mouth open. It must’ve taken him 5 minutes before he could speak.
He got me nothing.
One time, just one time, it made me cry. It was after my sister & BIL’s five year anniversary, and she showed me this lovely little pink flawed diamond ring he had got her. I held it together but burst into tears on the way home. I told him why and felt so incredibly stupid and petty. But I can’t help it, that was nearly three years ago and I still feel sad about it. I could deal with all the Christmases and birthdays that he didn’t really get me anything thoughtful (I once got finger paints, and another time a note saying we would go on holiday, which we didn’t do), if he had got me anything for our ten year anniversary.
I shouldn’t complain. He’s a wonderful man, he really is. He loves me, helps me with everything, he’s generous, loves my family, boasts about me at work, tells me I’m beautiful, he rubs my back, fixes my mum’s computer, does silly dances to make me laugh. He remembers all our anniversaries, even the half-years. He makes me croissants for breakfast almost every weekend, and that’s no joke! He’s a dream and I am very lucky. But I did want, just for once, something that he thought about and picked out for me to mark the occasion.
It’s not the way he was raised. My in-laws, who I adore, get me really thoughtful and far too generous gifts. My FIL got me my first ever new-from-a-shop bicycle. My late grandmother-in-law only started giving me 10 euro notes long after she couldn’t leave the house any more to go shopping, and then after she could no longer knit me things.
If he asks I’ll tell him things I would like, I remind him he could ask my sisters, my mum, his sister, or any of our mutual friends to go shopping with him. I randomly tell him things that I need: gloves, a scarf. It’s not a case of too-subtle hints, it’s not that I say not to get me anything. We do gifts for Christmas, he loves everything I get him. (Really, last year I got him a tent and he was so happy he wanted to sleep in it out in the garden.)
I think it’s just that he is really not materialistic himself, which I think is a nice quality in him. But as this thread makes clear, it’s the thought that you really want for Christmas. I wouldn’t care if he wrote me a song, baked me a cake, knitted me socks or made me a coaster out of dental sticks, if it just showed that he thought about me.
It’s not going to happen. I need to pull myself together and stop reading this thread. He’s wonderful and he has one flaw. I need to just let it go. Normally I’m good at it. Like I said, the only time I really cared was the anniversary. It’s fine: he loves me and he shows me in other ways. OK. Good to go again. Phew. Thanks for listening.