An Expensive Gift...now what?

Two years ago, I was professionally matched as a mentor with a women in a fellowship. Once the fellowship had completed, the mentorship developed into a primarily work-focused friendship. With COVID, we’ve been meeting via Zoom every few weeks and discussion is largely around her career related stuff with a bit of personal conversation. She asks me for my professional advice and I give it to her.

Last year for the holiday, she gave me a very nice assortment of chocolates to which I wrote a nice thank you note. I do not give gifts (outside of my own kids), nor do I send holiday cards. This year, she asked me for my address (since everyone is teleworking) and I gave it to her, expecting a holiday card. Today a package arrived and it contained a beautiful designer leather handbag. I did a quick search and it retails for $200-$300. Maybe it could be purchased on sale for as low as $150.

I’m not a designer handbag person. Several years ago, I even stopped carrying a purse. (I carry a small clutch wallet with my ID, cash and phone.) I do not have the type of lifestyle that would fit a designer leather handbag–I frequent places like Tractor Supply, Lowes and Aldi. My personal life is very different than my professional life, but even in my typical pre-covid professional life, a designer handbag wouldn’t fit.

I have no idea what to do with this (aside from writing her a very nice thank you note). It’s probably the most expensive item clothing-wise I now own. I could potentially sell it online (I do eBay & Poshmark), but she knows I resell online and it wouldn’t be difficult for her to find my account. I don’t want to hurt her feelings or embarrass her by giving it back. Regifting it at this expense level isn’t a reality for me.

I’m at a loss on how to proceed from here. Thoughts?

Find a friend or family member who can sell it for you on eBay. Then use the proceeds in a way that you find meaning in, be it something utilitarian from Lowe’s or Aldis or a donation to a cause you support.

I suspect she might have been in the same situation you now find yourself in and she handled it by regifting the purse to you. You selling it would break that chain and get something nice to into hands that want it.