Here’s my idea.
Establish who are all the most popular characters in the modern serieseses, and cut away those who aren’t likely to want to return to play them again.
So you might get, from Voyager, the Doc, Chakotay, and Seven. From DS:9 maybe Jadzia Dax (I know, but I liked her, and in Trek you can bring back the dead) and Odo and okay, maybe Kira (though I never liked her much). And in TNG you could have Tom Riker, Barclay, ummmm whoever. I dunno, they’re all getting old now. And of course a bunch of new folks.
Here’s the premise.
Voyager returns to the whatever-it-is Quadrant to discover that the Federation is in tatters. There has been a fullscale pangalactic war, and the whole galaxy is in chaos. Everyone, including the standard bad guys like The Dominion, the Romulans, the Klingons, everybody, are all in terrible states of devastation.
And it’s the job of the ragtag Federation survivors to:
- (first season) piece together what happened, and who is responsible.
- (second season) gather resources, allies, etc to establish a stronghold
- (third season) make their first vollies, attacks, sorties, to test the waters and learn more about their foe.
Etc etc etc
All through the series of course there are the usual sideline, non-story-arc tales. But what is cool is that there’d be a lot more danger. Nobody would know who was trustworthy and who wasn’t, and there’d be a ton of tension between characters always. Characters could die at any time. Lots of action (which the trekkers love and want more of) plus room for more character-based tales, and still space for SF allegories etc.
And in the first episode of the first season, the Voyager explodes and takes that dickhead wanker Tom Paris with it.
This is the kind of pull-out-all-the-stops action packed fun blockbuster series Trek needs to really define itself again, imho.
And this would rock!