An Ode to an Oak Tree (with Pictures)

It saddens me to have to cut down on of these giants (picture) . This one wasn’t as big as some, but it was big enough. It stood at the crest of the hill overlooking Mill Creek. Year after year, this tree provided bushels of acorns for squirrel and deer. Its branches provided homes for countless birds. Year after year, its leaves fell to the ground, feeding back some of the nutrients that it took from the soil in the spring. From time to time, I rested in its shade. A tree this size serves to remind me that I am but a small, insignificant part to the sum of the life on this planet. It’s good for me to have such reminders when I get to feeling a little too self-important.

But, unfortunately, lightning stuck this tree about the same time that hurricane Rita blew through East Texas a couple of years ago. The lightning didn’t kill it, but it left a two inch scar along the length of the trunk and knocked away quite a bit of bark. It also broke off a large limb near the top. I knew it was only a matter of time before insects and decay inflicted terminal damage to this tree. So I made the decision to cut it while I could still make some useful lumber from it. I make this decision a year ago, but events seem to overwhelm me and I didn’t do it last winter like I had hoped.

A few months ago, a friend heard about someone in dire straights that could use some firewood, so he asked me if I had some. I cut and split the broken limb over the Christmas holiday. It filled his pickup bed with good firewood. So, this tree benefited yet one more person before it went down.

Two weeks ago, I decided it was time. I didn’t want to wait until Spring when the sap would start moving back up to feed the budding leaves. But alas, when I started the saw, the chain jammed. I disassembled the saw to discover that the drive sprocket was fractured. The tree had received a two week reprieve; a last-second stay of execution was granted by the chainsaw gremlins.

This last Friday afternoon, with the repaired saw in hand (picture) , I cut it down. I botched the wedge cut a little, but the tree politely fell right where I wanted it to go. I had chosen a spot to minimize the number of pine saplings that would be damaged when the giant fell. The tree’s limbs and the small pines kept it from falling all of the way to the ground. This can be both a blessing and a curse. It’s good to have the trunk and limbs up off the ground. But, it puts the trunk in a pinch that can cause little booby traps when you saw into it (picture) .

I squared of the end of the trunk to make a cleaner saw log. Then I counted its rings. I carefully counted 147 rings (picture) . That means this tree started growing in 1860. The Civil War was ragin and Lincoln was presdent when this tree was a sapling. Actually, Jefferson Davis was president in this part of the county. This tree was well established when the 1900 hurricane that destroyed Galveston blew through this country. I counted out to those rings. The years around 1900 must have been wetter than usual because there were four of five wide rings in those years.

There was once a house about 50 yards south of where this tree stood. There’s still a little clearing there that I keep cleared for sentimental reasons. There are a couple of ancient pear trees at the edge of the clearing. My grandmother told me she remembers when there were still furrows from a garden there. It’s possible that kids played on and around this tree.

I remembered my dad telling of the drought in the 1950’s and I counted from the outside inward to those rings. The 1940s and 50s must have been pretty dry; the rings were narrow and tight.

I sawed three saw logs six feet long before reached the major limbs. I was afraid to make them any longer because I knew the logs would be near the lift capacity of the tractor. I was right, the bottom log was a full load (picture) .

The heartwood in the logs has a good red oak color. The top log has a couple of knots that will reduce on the amount of usable lumber. Once it dries, the grain will be fairly open, as is common with red oak. But, it’s usually easy to work with and finishes easily to a beautiful natural color.

If all goes well, I should be able to saw these logs into furniture lumber sometime this spring. I’ll stack them and let them air dry for a couple of years. Then perhaps someday by-and-by I’ll get the chance to make some furniture from it. Maybe I can make a rocking chair that a mother can use to rock her new child to sleep. Maybe I can make a dining table that a family can gather round to share memories. I hope I can make something worthy of this noble oak that will allow it to live on another 147 years.

Nice post. I often feel awed by the presence of large old trees - there’s a huge banyan tree near where I live at home that must be several hundred years old, at least. It has a definite presence, and there’s a sense of being connected to something larger than myself when I sit under it.

Wow, Tully Mars, beautifully written. The photo of you counting the rings has a nice balance of old-time logger and modern forester to it. I can’t wait to see you sawing it into lumber.

What do you do with the top part once you get to the branches? Make smaller lumber, or move on to firewood?

Tully Mars that was touching and beautiful. What a great thread and what a great way to honor the old Oak.

How do you cut the Oak into useable lumber? What type of saw do you use and what type of lumber do you get?

When I had to take down a 50-year-old oak, I just chopped it down to firewood. I am slowly burning it a few logs at a time and in a few years I will probably have to give much of it to my BIL as he uses firewood much quicker than I do.

Jim

Wonderful post. As a dirt worshipping tree hugger, I must say I would rather a gentle spirit such as yourself cutting that wonderful tree into logs than a paper mill clearcutting an entire forest.

That said, your last sentence truly touched me, and I do hope you can do the right thing with that tree. You have honored it well by posting this thread…I hope to see pics of whatever you make in the future. A table perhaps, a chair, a bench a worthy plaque. Good on you!

Just wanted to let you know that you are right about this:

The early 50’s were the driest on record (in the South) with the years from 1953-1957 being the driest ever. I think we may have eclipsed that here with 2000 or 2001. :slight_smile:

Very cool post, Tully Mars, and thanks for putting it on here for us to see. I’ll be keen to find out what happens as well – do please give us the heads up in two years plus time!

A good telling of the passing of an elder.

Please plant a new oak.

Tris

Like this. In this picture, I’m sawing pine that was killed by beetles this last summer into 1" x 8" paneling for a relative.

How about some of the things I’ve built in the past from similar trees? Like this, this, and this.

That’s a good thought. However, so far I’ve found that nature does a much better job than I can. I’ve planted nearly a thousand pine seedlings, of which maybe a dozen have survived. In that same time in other areas, they come up like lawn grass. The squirrels seem to be my best friends when it comes to planting oaks, walnuts, and pecans. The ‘hole’ created by the absence of this oak will allow the surrounding pine saplings to get more sunlight and they will grow faster to dominate that little area. Then I, or someone, will harvest the pines and the little oaks will sprout up through the pine straw and the cycle repeats.

Very nice. Very nice indeed. Funny, I’ve only met a few people in my area of Connecticut that do similar things that you have done. They are all good chaps! Fun to kick around and swap stories with. I come from a town that has an old seaport in it. It still has a wooden boat shipyard as well. After Katrina, some of the local ship wrights went down to New Orleans and ended up coming back with six (6) flat bed semis full of white, red oaks. Some 36"+ diameter They will be used for ships like the Amistad and other old whalers, reconstructions and new alike. I’m sure a trip to that lumber yard would raise your eye brow a bit. I love going down there and watching their progress in whatever they are doing. neat stuff.

Just curious, but did you save any acorns from it? You could try to replace the tree with one of its own offspring.

I have a bunch of huge old black walnut trees. I’d like to get rid of a couple of them, but we can’t afford it and don’t know how to do it safely in a heavily wooded area. But one of these days…as soon as I find someone who will give me the supposed big bucks for the wood, I’ll sell them to the first bidder.

I wrote a thread on this quite a while ago. It is not easy to do…Acorns usually sprout when they lay half submerged on their side, then getting past the first three seasons with no deer eating below the buds is tough to do. I had limited success when I filled a 5 gallon bucket with acidic earth from an oak grove…put a few acorns on top of the soil and left them for a year. 1 sprouted and subsequently died. Oaks are a hearty bunch for a reason…they only grow in optimal conditons. Usually acidic soil and not a lot of under growth.

Advertise in a free paper for free lumber - you cut and haul it’s yours - type of thing. I did it when we lived in our old house a few years ago… the “free lumber” ad really cought some attention.

Where are you? I don’t need specifics (yet), just tell me what state. please.

Wow and Wow. That is a heck of a saw rig and great craftsmanship on the furniture you built.

Jim

Saddens me about the tree but I appreciate that you’re wanting to act before decay begins. Do you just harvest from your acreage or have you access to other mature stands?

I believe I’m probably south and west of you a piece but likely the same forest and the same damn bark beetles. Harpoon is costing me a small fortune every few years as I attempt to avoid what many of my neighbors have let happen. What % do you think you’ve lost in the last say 10 years? I’m guessing we’re at 30 to 40% mortality and it’s nowhere near run it’s course. Don’t want to see happen to our Longleaf Pines what became of the American Chestnut.

You’re an artist, Tully.

Tris

If I remember right, this place is about 130 miles up HWY 59 from you. I grew up there, but my paying job keeps me in the DFW area most of the time. The turpentine beetles hit me hard this last summer.

I’ve about 40 acres of timber and I’ve been losing 2-3 pines a year in the 10 years I’ve been responsible for the place. That is, until this last summer. The old-timers tell me that in a good year, the pines can fight off the beetles by isolating the eggs with sap. However, the drought this last year handicapped them. I’ve cut 15-20 within the last 12 months. I still have about half of them piled up waiting to saw. That old saw has about a 50% duty cycle: an hour of repair per hour of sawing. And that’s an improvement over when I got it back (it was my grandfather’s). Only being able to work on it a couple of days a month doesn’t help.

I have two huge old Chestnuts. I keep saying I’m need to try to get some saplings started from them and plant them.

Thanks. I hope to be one when I grow up (if I ever do). Actually, I see the work of the real artists in Fine Woodworking and realize I’ve a long way to go. I look at pictures of Sam Maloof’s work and dream.