Anyone else out there adore Jonathan Carroll?

I had a witty, erudite, and convincing post about just how amazingly life-changing Jonathan Carroll’s fiction is, but the hamsters ate it, so we’ll settle for the succint breeze-through.

When I was young, books were more important to me than people. People tended to be small-minded, silly, disappointing, or all three. The characters in books were more interesting and inspiring than any actual people that I ever met, and it was more important to me that Lucy and Peter and Susan and Edmund got help from Aslan than it was that my classmates or family ever talked to me. As I grew older and (at least in theory) more mature, I changed what types of fiction I prefer and the characters (and their stories) became less integral to my life. Sure, it was still interesting to read about the Red Crosse Knight or Humbert Humbert, but they weren’t people I loved and hated (sometimes at the same time) anymore. Carroll’s fiction takes me back to the time when I cared about the characters like they were good friends. I hope for them, I love them for their achievements, I hate them for their faults, I stride through their worlds as my own. No other living modern author (proper respect must be paid to Mr. Faulkner) has been able to rekindle that in me.

Truly, that would pretty much be enough to make me love the guy. Fortunately for me, however, that’s not all his books deliver. He also writes like a god. His prose is as finely crafted as any I’ve ever read. In fact, I’d say it’s the closest thing I’ve ever read to poetry wrought into prose that wasn’t written by John Donne, but I don’t expect you to take my word for it. No, instead, read the quotation with which I opened this post, or even just check out some of the titles of his novels: Voice of our Shadow, Bones of the Moon, Sleeping in Flame, A Child across the Sky, The Marriage of Sticks, or my personal favorite, From the Teeth of Angels.

Anyway, the point of all this is that if you don’t know Jonathan Carroll, you should check him out. Not only do I recommend him, but he’s the guest of honor at the World Fantasy Convention this year (and his last novel, The Wooden Sea, is nominated for the World Fantasy Award), and Neil Gaiman, Garth Ennis, Graham Joyce, and Terry Pratchett say you should. And if you are acquainted with this wonderful writer, post here and show solidarity!

Consider my solidarity duly shown… I ran into A Child Across the Sky some years ago, and that was my introduction to Carroll. He’s a writer of tremendous skill, and his books are involving (and disturbing) on a number of levels.

My personal favourite, I think, is Sleeping in Flame… I just loved that ending!

I loved Sleeping in Flame, was really disturbed by Bones of the Moon (in a good way), wished Black Coctail was longer… but my favorite is Outside the Dog Museum, it’s a little bit lighter than his other books, but far from shallow.

I got the Ace paperback edition of LAND OF LAUGHS 'cause I fell in love with the cover. I read it and fell in love with Carroll’s writing. I’m not as fond of his newer stuff (WOODEN SEA, MARRIAGE OF STICKS, BEEHIVE), but his early and middle period stuff is some of the best fantasy ever written.

If I HAD to pick a favorite, it’d be LAND OF LAUGHS, but there’re so many good ones!

Fenris

I couldn’t finish SLEEPING IN FLAME.

His literary agent sent me some of his more recent stuff, the more-or-less detective novels. I didn’t like those either, and declined to publish them.

I got all excited when THE LAND OF LAUGHS was re-issued, because I’d heard such great things about it, and I bought it and managed to finish it, but I didn’t like it very much.

I don’t think I’ll be reading him any more. I find his prose cloying, his grasp of narrative sketchy, and he is constantly introducing characters from whom I’d run like a bunny rabbit if I encountered them in real life.

So I guess you should put me down in the “Doesn’t Adore Jonathan Carroll” column, huh?

[sub] the above comments are subjective and the author does not intend to disparage those who enjoy Mr. Carroll’s work.[/sub]

A friend turned me on to Carroll recently, and I really enjoyed his books. I especially liked the short story book, the title of which I can’t remember right now.

THE PANIC HAND