Anyone know who covered "Elsewhere"?

I was just listening to Evans Blue’s cover of “Possession” which made me remember something I’ve been trying to figure out for quite a while…

Two and a half or three years ago, I heard a cover of Sarah McLachlan’s “Elsewhere” on the radio. It was around the time that an actress sang it on One Tree Hill, but I don’t think that’s very important. Anyway, I have no idea who did the cover, but it was done with a male lead singer, so it wasn’t from the show.

I’m hoping A. it wasn’t done by a local group (local music only accounted for about 5% of what the station played, so hopefully not) B. someone else at least heard it, even if they don’t know who did it.

Any clues?