Are charges of Assault on a Police officer more sever than Assault?

Every once in a while I will see an article in the news that states that a person was charged with Assault on a police officer. I always wonder if that is different or more severe than Assault.

In Virginia it is:

Pennsylvania too, for that matter:

and

Subsection c of the code includes police.

I suspect it almost always is.

In Virginia, to pick an example I am familiar with, Code § 18.2-51.1 provides in pertinent part:

Note that a Class 6 felony in Virginia ordinarily carries a sentence of one to five years, or (at the discretion of the sentencing authority) confinement in jail for not more than 12 months and a fine of not more than $2,500, either or both. So this crime is a felony conviction with a mandatory one-year minimum sentence.

In contrast, § 18.2-57 defines an ordinary assault and battery as a Class 1 misdemeanor, for which the penalty is at most a year in jail and a fine of $2,500.

Even and assault and battery with no bodily injury against a police officer is treated more severely: a Class 6 felony with a mandatory minimum sentence six months.

In many, if not all, states in the United States, Assault of a Law Enforcement Officer, is a felony. If the same act were committed against a victim not of that category, the assault would be a misdemeanor. The same is true of Battery on a Law Enforcement Officer. A simple battery (misdemeanor) becomes a felony if the victim is a law officer.

Other stipulations include that the victim may be of a broader category that just “police”. For instance, she may be a correctional officer. This varies with state. What does not generally vary with state is that the victim must be operating in his official capacity, and the perpetrator must know that the victim is of the category, i.e., a cop. This last is known as scienter, a necessary and requisite knowledge on the part of the perpetrator.

States generally justify the distinction as being necessary to provide for, or enhancing, the protection of law enforcement officer.

I hope this helps.

Yes, an assault on a police officer is a far more serious crime than an assault on a regular person. Since this is GQ, I will stop there.

Same in Texas.

  • Assault is a class A misdemeanor, while assault on a public servant (including peace officers) is a third degree felony.

  • Aggravated assault is a second degree misdemeanor, aggravated assault on a public servant a first degree felony.

  • Murder is a first degree felony, murder of a peace officer is a capital crime punishable by death.

My esteemed colleague, pravnik, was typing a bit fast here. He meant, “Aggravated assault is a second degree felony.” Misdemeanors in Texas are Class A, B, or C.

Whoops, yeah. Thanks for catching that. No such thing as a “second degree misdemeanor” in Texas!

So why is it less bad to punch someone who’s not a law enforcement officer?

Section 270 of the Canadian Criminal Code specifically describes assaults on peace officers, though the penalty isn’t different than conventional assault.

It certainly should be more severe, but that’s GD territory.

I’ve wondered about a related issue:

What if the cop is undercover?

What if the cop is off duty and you don’t know s/he’s a cop?

-FrL-

In Texas, at least, this is covered in the statute: the offense only gets a more severe punishment if the defendant assaults a person he “knows is a public servant while the public servant is lawfully discharging an official duty.” Texas Penal Code section 22.01(b)(1). It’s presumed that the defendant knew that the person was a public servant if that person is wearing a conspicuous badge or uniform. Otherwise, it’s a simple assault.