[QUOTE=spoke-]
So what are you saying? If one criticizes Israel (unless they are carefully meek in their criticism) we must assume that this person is an anti-Semite?
That certainly sounds to me like a debate-killer. No one may dare criticize Israel, lest they be presumed a bigot.
If we are ever to have a rational debate, I think it better to assume otherwise until proven wrong, rather than indulge in innuendo and name-calling.
At any rate, calling your opponent in a debate an anti-Semite is still an ad hominem attack, even if true, since it adds nothing to the debate and is irrelevant to the resolution of whatever issue may be under discussion.
See how the debate in this very thread has been sidetracked into an argument over whether Tutu is a bigot?
[/QUOTE]
If you are interested in the study of fallacies in argument, the exchange above is illustrative. I would say that it demonstrates the right-and the wrong- way of approaching the twin fallacies of “appeal to authority” and “ad hominem” attack.
The important thing to note is that neither an appeal to authority nor a characterization of a person’s position based on what they say is of necessity a fallacy. Some people actually are authorities, and this does give their opinions more weight; stating that a person is not objective on a matter may actually detract from that weight. It depends on circumstances.
For example, look at the exchange above. A poster cites Bishop Tutu on the ME. He is obviously using an appeal to authority - the implication being that Tutu, as a moral exemplar, is above accusations of bias. Thus we should heed his subjective opinion.
I then cite a quotation from the statement of Bishop Tutu which, I contend, clearly demonstrates that he is biased. This isn’t an ad hominem attack on Tutu - it is a refutation of the appeal to authority made by the person citing Tutu in the first place!
A fallacious ad hominum would look like this:
- You can’t trust Bishop Tutu’s arguments. He is an Anglican Bishop, and Anglicans are all well-known Jew-haters.
Not like this:
- You are giving Bishop Tutu’s opinions weight because of the respect he has earned [appeal to authority]. You have claimed Bishop Tutu is objective and not biased. However, in examining his statement, he demonstrates bias in the following manner [cite]. Thus, I conclude he is in fact biased. I conclude your appeal to authority should be discounted.
In conclusion, an analysis of the validity of sources, such as whether to grant an appeal to authority status, does not “add nothing to the debate” and is not a “fallacy”. Indeed, such an analysis is the very essence of informed debate.