When Bricker posts a conservative opinion, he sometimes gets slammed by some for being conservative. Fair enough.
When Bricker posts a politically neutral legal opinion, he sometimes gets slammed by some for being conservative. WTF?
Unfortunately, there is little that mods could do with this problem, for it is not a mod’s job to run about officially warning posters that their opinions are stupid, particularly when the mod is not a legal authority.
Nor is a backlash of stupid conservative flames a useful solution to the problem of stupid liberal flames.
The solution is rather circular, for if more rational and well spoken conservatives, such as Sam Stone, were to participate on the Boards, then stupid liberal posters would be marginalized, just as presently the stupid conservative posters are marginalized, but for this to happen, the Boards must be more welcoming to rational conservative posters, and this will not happen until the stupid liberal posters are marginalized. It’s a bootstrapping problem.
I think that the best we can do is to try to be attentive to a poster’s arguments, rather than that poster’s general political bent.
In that respect, I think that the mods do a very good job, for although some of them participate vigorously as posters on political issues, they are careful to not let it conflict with their actions as mods, and more to the point, when they participate as posters, they tend to discuss arguments, rather than blindly attack (Manny excepted).
I would not want the mods to be prohibited from posting. That would remove some of the most articulate and rational posters from the Boards – just the sort of posters we need if the Boards are to welcoming to posters of all political bents.