Army to lead-poison part of Iowa on Friday

Very early in the thread an alternative was mentioned.

The EPA has a way to mitigate lead azide, but Hegseth’s Army is going with the “blow this shit up” method. Now, it’s possible those other methods aren’t feasible due to specific circumstances here, but I’m not just going to trust them because we know they’ve got the best leaders making decisions and taking public safety and environmental concerns to heart.

Per the above cites it’s eventually going to blow up on its own, so a controlled explosion now is better than an unexpected and uncontrolled explosion later, and I doubt Hegseth is personally making calls on hazardous waste disposal in Iowa.

So, after this stuff goes through whatever chemical reaction makes it blow up, what form or forms will the lead be in, and how bioavailable is lead in those forms?

I’m a chemist by education and previously worked in environmental remediation – never explosives, but plenty of lead and other abandoned chemicals. I agree with @smithsb that things never would have reached this state with competent people paying attention, but unfortunately the time for alternatives has passed.

Chemical neutralization ideally would be done in a controlled facility, and given the transportation risk, that’s not possible. So how do you treat it in place? Lift the barrels and put into a treatment vessel? BOOM!! Pry open the lids and pour the chemicals in? Just opening corroded lids is likely to trigger an explosion. If you manage to get the container open, the physical impact of liquid on the dry crystals will probably do it, and now an explosion includes not only lead but whatever treatment chemicals you were attempting to use[1]. And if all the original liquid in the barrels has disappeared, it’s a good bet that the barrels aren’t going to contain the hazardous sludge created by the treatment. Really, chemical neutralization or wetting is no longer an option.

The only hope at this point is if the Army uses effective plume mitigation measures to keep the lead as local as possible. It’s certainly fair to criticize them in that regard if they demonstrate the same level of incompetence that brought them to this point.


  1. and I’m not even getting into the fact that the suggested treatment by the EPA (MuniRem) is not a permitted technology for lead azide ↩︎

More information on the plume mitigation plan is available:
Physical Mitigation Measures at the Blast Site

  • In-Place Detonation: Moving the unstable, recrystallized lead azide was deemed too dangerous, so the Army selected controlled, in-place detonation inside an earth-covered, explosion-proof magazine area. [1, 2, 3]
  • Soil Wetting and Water Sprayers: Crews are wetting the surrounding soil and deploying water sprayers and misting systems directly above the buried concrete bunker to capture heavy lead particles and bind them to the concrete/soil upon detonation. [1, 2, 3]
  • Sand Barrier: A sand barrier has been erected around the bunker to absorb blast energy and limit airborne debris. [1, 2]
  • Incineration: Plant officials note that the high heat of the intentional detonation is engineered to incinerate a significant portion of the explosive material. [1]

Monitoring and Sampling Plan

  • Air and Environmental Monitoring: Under an emergency EPA RCRA permit, the Army has set up perimeter air monitors to track lead dust levels in real time before, during, and after the blasts. [1, 2]
  • Post-Blast Cleanup & Testing: Environmental sampling of the blast radius will occur immediately after, and local property owners can volunteer for soil testing or file damage/cleanup claims through the Army. [1, 2]
  • Plume Tracking Maps: The Army is releasing and updating localized air and surface dust dispersion modeling maps (48 hours, 6 hours, and hourly leading up to the event). [1, 2]

Evacuation and Community Safety Recommendations

  • Mandatory/Cautionary Evacuation: Residents in the Middletown City Park neighborhood are asked to evacuate from 8:00 AM to 2:00 PM due to the risk of ground vibrations causing localized window damage. [1, 2, 3]
  • Evacuation Center: An official shelter is open at the Armed Forces Reserve Center (16815 DMC Hwy 34 / Highway 79, Middletown, IA 52638), which accommodates families and pets (in carriers or on leashes) with refreshments. [1, 2]
  • Regional Plume Precautions: Modeling predicts elevated air lead particles or surface dust spanning areas from Burlington north toward the Quad Cities and Wapello/New Boston. For people in or near projected paths, officials recommend:
    • Staying indoors and avoiding outdoor air during the passage of the plume.
    • Keeping doors and windows closed.
    • Setting HVAC systems to “recirculate” mode.
    • Avoiding unnecessary travel through impacted zones.
    • Washing parked cars at a car wash and wiping down or hosing off outdoor/indoor surfaces (like children’s play areas and windowsills) once the all-clear is given. [1, 2, 3]

As I understand it, most of the lead will be converted to elemental lead in the nanometer to microns size, and much of that will create lead oxides in the air. Elemental lead and lead oxides are highly bioavailable, especially small particles that are inhaled. Over time (years), lead binds to soil minerals and organic material, which are a little less bioavailable but still bad to eat.

Well then, I hope they film it and we can watch it like when they used to blow shit up in Mythbusters. At least then some good comes of it.

Yeah, I read that. The only real plume mitigation measure I see in there is water sprayers. All the rest is either for the explosion itself or monitoring so people downwind know just how fucked they are.

For the sprayers, how much water are they using? Over how big an area? What’s the droplet size? How far downwind will they continue to spray? Do they have contingencies if the wind speed is over a certain limit at the scheduled time? Maybe they’re doing this right (or as right as possible), and maybe they’re only going through the motions.

All things considered, I’d rather live near the Chiquita Canyon garbage geyser than in that part of soon to be lead-poisoned Iowa.

It should be noted that Hammett’s Red Harvest starts out “I first heard Personville called Poisonville by a red-haired mucker named Hickey Dewey in the Big Ship in Butte.” - one of the all-time great lines in hard-boiled detective fiction.

*Hickey Dewey also called his shirt a shoit.
**The BIg Ship was an apartment building, apparently not one of the classier joints in town.

I didn’t click your link but I’m imagining a pit filled with banana peels.

See here & following posts for more on the trash geyser. It’s a lot funnier (from 100+ miles way) than any pile of bananas.

Like this Army detonation thing, it’s another clear example of an entity, in that case a private business, cheaping out on managing the concentrated risk they created over years and were charged with safeguarding indefinitely until it has quite literally had a blowout in their faces.

It’s on the opposite corner of Iowa from Sioux City.

I hope we don’t need a bigger Iowa.

In 2012, a landfill in eastern Iowa caught fire, and my dad, who was a city firefighter for 36 years, said, “Good luck putting that out.” IDK if they ever did.

The Centralia fire, which was also started by burning garbage, isn’t expected to go out for centuries.

The Centralia fire is in a coal seam.

So we are at the level of nuking it from orbit again? OK. Is Iowa… necessary? expendable? can it still be evacuated?

Yes, I know.

I was making a funny about the toxicity of Sioux City. :wink:

Sure, but not live through the process.

I don’t think there are any processes that a dead whale can live through. Necromancy maybe?