WhiteLightning, I have given your questions their very own post.
Yes, there is variation in the strength of the drinks I make, but not so much as you might think. I always start everyone off with a good pour, and unless you’re a godawful tipper–like a quarter per drink, or round, or whatever–your drinks will stay that way. It’s more than just the tips; it’s about building a bar. I want people at my bar b/c they attract more people; I want cute girls at my bar b/c they attract men, and prevent the dreaded “sausage fest.” So even if a girl is a horrible tipper–and trust me, that’s most of 'em!–chances are good I won’t short-pour her and her friends b/c I want them to stay.
I want money over the long haul; I want people at my bar all night long, attracting other people, so you have to really annoy me, or not tip me at all, for me to deliberately short-pour your drink. But I have no qualms about it, if it comes to that. (I also short-pour for people who look a bit too drunk; cutting someone off is an ugly business and I’d rather avoid it unless it’s really necessary, so usually I’ll just start making their drinks really weak.)
And yes, a really good tipper gets really good drinks. And my definition of a “really good tipper” is someone who’ll tip me two/three bucks on a single drink. Five bucks on a round of two/three drinks. Giving me the change on a $20 for a $14 tab. This is the guy/gal whose drinks are made quickest and strongest. I make them my priority.
But these are really good tippers; I don’t expect them nor look for them. A dollar a drink is pretty much a good rule of thumb if you don’t want to get crazy with it, particularly if you’re in a large group or keep ordering big rounds of drinks and shots. Someone who keeps ording three beers, two margaritas, a Crown and Coke, a dirty martini, and three kamikazis is a HUGE pain in the ass unless they’re making it worth my while, so I’m going to ignore a time-consuming order like that until I have time, unless this person makes it worth my while…because if I made all those drinks individually, for other people, I’d make a lot more money than the two/three bucks this person plans on giving me for making all of it together.
And yes, regulars do get special treatment. I know what they drink, so it’s waiting for them by the time they sit down; I know their names and we usually have an ongoing conversation/debate going, so that starts up the moment they show up. I don’t always “hook up” regulars, b/c I don’t want a bar full of people who regularly show up for free alcohol; this is counterproductive. I want a regular who behaves him or herself, is friendly and polite, and tips well. Not outrageously; I don’t expect 40% or anything from a regular. Just a good 20-25% will work.
But I do have a couple of regulars who come in who tip so well that their tab is very minimal. One of them is another bartender who works down the street; her tab is rarely over $15 regardless of what she drinks, and she’ll tip me at least $20.
Having said that, it’s never a good idea as a regular to stop tipping what you began tipping when you started coming in. But if you are a regular who comes in and always tips 20%, any decent bartender will be happy to see you, so you don’t have to tip outrageously in order to get good service as a regular.
And regulars I don’t like–creepy guys who come in a lot, or have a tendency to get insulting when they get a little drunk, or who don’t tip well and never have–get absolutely no special treatment at all. I “forget” their names and what they drink, and they actually get treated worse than random customers.
So if you’re a “wanted” regular, you’ll know it. So just carry on as you’ve begun.