At what point did Aragorn pop Arwen's cherry?

Does this mean that in all future threads, no matter what the subject, “If the word sex or sheep is posted then eventually in the thread a link to Hal’s famous post must be made”?

IMHO, sadly, yes. When you become a legend (even through no fault of your own), it tends to stay.

Wow, kinda nice to have witnessed the beginning of a Meme.

Imagine the view from here…

Hmmmm…so when an elf maid becomes an ahem initiated she-elf, does her virginity awaken on its own in the Undying Lands?

Just wondering.