Automatic Cat Litter Box?

I’ve seen the ads and all for those “automatic” cat litter boxes. These things have an electric eye, or something, and scrape the “waste” into a container at some preset time after kitty uses the box. Any of the TM have experience with these things? How reliable are they mechanically? Does the scraper thing ever NOT scrape? And if does break, what about getting it fixed? How about clean up, robot vs. manual, dealing with the bags, or whatever the stuff is scooped into? Expense, how often do you have to change the bags, and how costly?

Background - 3 cat household, PlanMan is the sole litter box keeper, Mrs. PlanMan’s arthritis prevents her from bending down, PlanDaughter’s teen-ness (graduates HS in a couple weeks) gets in her way.

Opinions? Facts?

I’ve had mine for about 3 months. I like it cause I used to be really lazy about changing. BUT if your cats like to scoop they may scoop up a pile of littel large enough that the scop can’t scoop through it. But you just have to tilt it to the side to get everything low enough for it to work. I have 1 cat and the cartridge takes about 7 days to fill. 3 cats might make it every other day. Your cat litter MUST CLUMP QUICKLY. I have pretty good litter but even so every now and she’ll pee up a storm and it will stick to the scoop. But I’m still happy with it and so is my cat.

If you have 3 you might want to get at least 2.

Some people love these. Some people hate them. You’ve had one reply from someone who loves theirs, so now here’s a reply from someone who hates them.

I have three cats. I bought an automatic litter box, and for a week it was heaven. Then the trouble started.

Briefly:

  1. The motor is quiet at first. Then litter dust gets in it, and it gets louder, and louder…

  2. The sensor eyes get clogged with litter. When this happens, the box runs every 10 minutes. If you are asleep, the noise can be enough to wake you up. So you have to get out of bed to clean the sensors.

  3. The little bin everything gets scooped into is not airtight. So you still get the litter box smell.

  4. Because of the way the sides are constructed, if you have a male can who stands when he urinates, it will leak onto the floor.

  5. The litter box will run when a cat is in it. I watched in shock as my cat was pushed out of the box. But it only makes sense. After all, when the sensors are clogged with litter, the thing runs every 10 minutes. If the timer was being reset as they state in the ads, it wouldn’t run at all when the sensors are clogged.

  6. After a while, the motor gives out. I had mine replaced 3 or 4 times. Finally, I demanded a refund. I got it, but I was still out all the money I spent mailing it in to them for replacement.

As for your specific questions:

“Does the scraper thing ever NOT scrape?”
Yes. If your cat digs down to the bottom of the litter and urinates, the resulting clump will stick in the bottom of the box. When the “rakes” comes along, the lump will break apart. Some will get scooped, and some will be left behind.

“And if does break, what about getting it fixed?”
If you buy it at Wal-Mart or Target, you can try and take it back and exchange it for a new one. I had to mail mine in when it broke. They then sent me a new one. When it broke, I had to pay shipping to send it to them, plus $20. They sent me a new one, and it broke…but I’ll stop ranting about that now.

How about clean up, robot vs. manual, dealing with the bags, or whatever the stuff is scooped into?
Occasionally you’re probably going to want to dump the old litter out and scrub the box. As I remember the bottom of the tray slides out. So that part’s fairly easy to clean. But in my experience, with three cats, the sides needed to be scrubbed too. It was difficult to do this, because you can’t get the motor wet.

Expense, how often do you have to change the bags, and how costly?
The clumps are raked into a long rectangular bin at the end of the box. It has a lid, which keeps some of the odor in, but it’s not airtight. You can put the lid on the container, seal it, and throw it away. But this will get expensive. It costs $15 for 12 of them. I just dumped the bin into a wastebasket with a lid I keep in the garage. Every once in a while, when it got really dirty, I would replace it.

The thing that makes me angry about this, is I wanted it to work. On the rare days when it worked it was fantastic. But most days I ended up having to get out of bed to clean the sensor eyes, empty the bin, scoop out what had been missed, clean the sensors again, etc. It was more trouble than it was worth.

But to be fair, a lot of people like these boxes. Here’s a link to a consumer review site. You’ll see a lot of different opinions here.

http://www.epinions.com/pets-Cats-Litter_Boxes-All-Litter_Maid_Advanced_Deluxe_Litter_Maid_Litter_Box/show_~allop

So, basically, it’s not Star Trek.

Better stick with the old-fashioned method, ladies and Germans.

We had the Littermaid for about a year. It was sort of a good idea, but it got clogged easily, and with 4 cats the thing at the end that it scoops into can pile up and overflow faster than you’d expect. It’s also pretty gross changing it out, as there is usually poo and stuff stuck all over. It’s VERY loud.

We now have two of these: http://www.drsfostersmith.com/product/prod_Display.cfm?pCatId=788 and we love them. You have to do it every day, but it’s simple. Just roll it over, roll it back, and pull out a little drawer and dump it out.

[list][]I have multiple cats and, as has been noted, this means rapid changing. Sorta defeats the purpose, IMO, of not having to change the thing as often. I scoop daily and change the litter every Sunday. Takes all of two minutes. When i go away on weekends or for work, the cats are fine for up to about 3, 3 1/2 days.[]I heard somewhere that clumping litter can be bad for cats, especially small ones, as the dust that remains on their paws, when licked off (during grooming) can form clumps in their tummies. That all I heard, not that the clumps would be big enough to do anything or that it would in any way hurt them (and the fact that so many people use clumping litter would tend to make me think is is safe, but…) 'Course, now they have those crystals that are supposed to be so much better than clay litter, so who knows?One of those things costs, what, about $100-$120? Litter runs me ~$5/25# bag which lasts ~2 weeks. You still need litter for the automatic box, so I just can’t see using it for any financial savings. Scoopin doesn’t bother me, so it’s not a squeemish factor, either. I just can’t find a reason to get one.

lesa, my son and I saw one of those and we both wondered what would happen if it started while a cat was still in it.
We thought it funny, but I’m sure your cat didn’t!

Anyone tried it for just one cat? I have been thinking about it for our little princess, who lets you know her box is dirty by pissing on your laundry pile. (Yes, I know I shouldn’t let it get that dirty- It’s finals week! Have a little sympathy!) Anyway, I figure for one kitty it should work OK.

Zette

I received one of these as a gift last year–an interesting choice when telling someone that their house needs more upkeep–and I have to say it didn’t made things any easier. I had the same problems as already stated by others with my 2 cats but here’s an added problem.

My little cat is a bit skittish and the thing literally scared the crap out of her. She got to the point the she wouldn’t use either box, neither the automatic nor the standard, due to the fact that she was freaked that the former moved. She started going on the floor of our bedroom or any other convenient place for her. It’s just her way of telling us that she’s not happy. I got rid of the automatic box and replaced it with another standard box. She’s happy again.

What’s so hard about taking less than one minute a day to manually scoop a couple of clumps out of the box?
I only have one cat, but it doesn’t seem to me like it would be worth the extra expense to buy and maintain one of those contraptions.
Besides, the high point of my cat’s day seems to be watching me humble myself cleaning up his mess.
Peace,
mangeorge

I had one with ONE cat. I loved it… but after awhile it seemed the motor lost most of its power and it would get stuck often. Its final days ended when I threw a chair and it landed on it. Broke for good.

I love mine. I have the littermaid. It has a sensor that sets off the rake to scoop 10 minutes after the cat has left the box. If it meets any resistance (a cat) it will go back to the starting position. If it can’t scoop the poop because of a build-up of litter (I am notorious for overfilling mine) it will try five times before giving up and the light will blink to let you know that it is clogged. I haven’t had any problems. The motor is a little loud but it has kept the house from stinking and was a big help when I was preg. and couldn’t clean the litter.I could let it go for days before getting hubby to clean it.
If you have the money I really would suggest investing in it, especially if you are as lazy as I am about cleaning the litter.