Bad blood donating experiences.

I’ve tried to give blood two times in the last year, both times unsuccessfully.

The first time, I got about halfway through and got dizzy and nauseated. I blamed it on the heat in the bloodmobile and my skipping breakfast. Scared the hell out of me.

Well, today I went to try to donate blood for my best friend’s baby. She’s going to have open heart surgery later this week and I just so happen to have her blood type (O+). I made sure to have a good lunch and drank plenty of liquids ahead of time. I made it about 3/4 of the way through and got sick again.

I feel upset that I’m trying to do a good thing here, but my body (or mind) keeps tripping me up. Has anybody else out there had similar experiences? If so, were you able to overcome this problem?


“It’s only common sense,
There are no accidents 'round here.”

Guy,

I’ve nurtured a loathing for needles throughout my life, partly as a result of lots of penicillin shots for throat infections as a young child; it used to take a platoon of nurses, my mom, and the doctor to hold me down. Consequently, I’ve never donated, though I’ve since made it through having blood taken for insurance physicals and for typing and other tests when my wife was pregnant with our first kid. Still don’t like it, but it doesn’t terrify me.

However, every time I consider donating, I remember my sister’s experience the first time she tried. She calmly and cooly stuck out her arm, got the needle in with no problems, etc. Partway through the process, her arm muscles involuntarily contracted and clenched up, drawing her hand up to her shoulder and driving the needle further in. Hurt like hell, and took quite a while to get her muscles relaxed enough to get the needle out.

So call me a wimp, but I don’t care to find out if the cause was genetic.

I relayed this story in GQ about two months ago:

I’ve given blood exactly once. In high school, I was refused because I have a mild heart condition (essentially a harmless murmur) and they wouldn’t accept me. Apparently, their rules have changed and my condition was recently amended to the “okay” list. Anyway, my first (and likely last) donation was last summer, for my father’s 6+ hour back surgery.

I was fine until the very end. Then, I felt faint and everything started going white. I remember being very, very sleepy–and very annoyed that the nurses kept yelling at me to open my eyes when I just wanted to sleep. Then I got nauseated, vomited twice, and nearly fainted again. Worst of all, I felt impending diarrhea and begged to be taken (carried, really) to the bathroom; they wouldn’t move me. Finally, when my blood pressure registered again (it dropped too low to measure), they carried me to their bathroom and I had them essentially holding me in place on the toilet. I’d be embarrassed, but it’s not like I could help it, and they were there to help me.

Over and over again the head nurse kept saying, “I really don’t recommend you donate blood again.” She probably said it as often as she did because of my wavering consciousness…wanted to make sure it got through to my head. I was there for nearly 2 hours before they okayed me to leave.

I had eaten a full meal and was quite hydrated. Is there a way to prevent that kind of reaction in the future? I don’t know, and unfortunately I doubt it. I also doubt I will ever try it again to find out. I just hope Dad appreciated every drop!


formerly known as LauraRae

I’m a Raggety Ann in a Barbie Doll world.

Laura’s Stuff and Things

OK, I want to post the opposing viewpoint here, because blood donation is a good thing.

I’ve donated blood regularly for more than 15 years, and never had a problem (except for the fact that it hurts a little bit.) Some places have better cookies than others (the reward for when you’re done), and some blood donation centers are nicer (one I went to had TV’s you could watch while you were giving blood), but all in all it’s a good experience. Just don’t tell the nurse “You remind me of Nurse Diesel in High Anxiety” before she puts the needle in your arm.

One of the first things I did when I quit smoking and got my weight over 110 pounds was start donating blood. Had absolutely no problems, donated regularly for a couple of years.

In 1991 I was told I couldn’t donate any more because I had contracted Hep C. (Don’t ask me how – my only risky behavior was having my ears pierced.) The Hep C was confirmed in private testing and I’m dealing with that, but it really ticks me off that now I can’t donate.

It’s one of the easiest things to do that makes you feel like maybe you’re helping someone. Shoot, you lay down, squeeze your fist a few times, doze off maybe, then scarf down the juice and cookies and go back to work. And people thank you for it!

Too bad there isn’t a way to tell ahead of time that you might have trouble.

But if you can pump out a few tubes full during your annual physical, donating should be a piece of cake.

I used to donate quite regularly. I’m B+ which, while not exactly rare, is shared by only about 10% of the population. The blood bank would call me from time to time as reserves of my type got low. Never got sick, but usually got close to passing out because my blood pressure has always tended to the low side. Didn’t bother me because it was temporary. It’s such a critical need that I’d ask anyone who could do it to consider regular donation. Must admit, though, that if every donation involved vomiting, I’d never have gone back a third time. Can’t donate anymore because I’ve had cancer, but I wholeheartedly support everyone who can, and encourage those who haven’t donated to do so. If it turns out to be a horrendous experience, you will at least have given it a try.

I went through a fair bit of chemotherapy as a child, so I used to be fairly comfortable with needles. They only bothered me if I couldn’t watch them go in. But they still hurt, and it often amused me and at other times irritated me when doctors and nurses tried to convince me that it doesn’t hurt.

They’d say, “Oh, but it’s just a little mosquito bite.”

…which is bullshit, and they know it.

One day in high school a nurse came by to talk to the class about giving blood, bullshitting everybody about how painless it was, and I was feeling cranky that day. I tried to keep the irritation out of my voice, but I mentioned that I had been through many medical treatments in my life and that I noticed she hadn’t addressed the many things that can go wrong. Including:

  1. Sometimes, blood will appear in the tube, and they’ll think the needle’s in the vein, but it will have actually poked all the way through and when they attempt to draw on it, it will cause a bruise.

  2. They don’t always tap the vein right the first time, but they won’t extract the needle all the way. Instead they’ll keep the point under your skin and fish around with the needle until they hit it.

  3. You might have what looks like a juicy vein that actually comes to a dead end or something. I’ve got one on my left arm that bruises badly anytime someone puts a needle to it. But anybody looking at it would think it’s a great vein.

  4. They could use butterfly needles, which have grips that allow easy inserstion of the needle at the proper angle. But instead they’ll probably use straight needles which are clumsier.

  5. The tourniquets are designed to pinch, and they sometimes pinch sharply. Plus, they will put your arm to sleep sometimes, because sometime it takes a lot of poking around to get the needle in the right place.

  6. The alcohol they swab you with is unpleasant to smell, and some people find it nauseous.

  7. When removing the needle, they will hold the alcohol pad down on the needle hard enough that it will hurt and will tend to push the needle around inside your skin where it doesn’t need to be. This in addition to the fact that the alcohol burns. They do this so that there will be pressure on the vein as soon as the needle vacates, to prevent the vein from `blowing out.’ Actually, they could safely pull the needle out quickly and then put pressure on the wounded vein with a piece of sterile cotton gauze. But most of them were never told this, and they won’t take your word for it no matter how much chemotherapy you’ve had.

The nurse chastised me for trying to scare people away. I did feel kind of bad about it. Not only was it for a good cause, by I myself have recieved several transfusions. I tried to redeem myself.

I said, “Ma’am, I found all this out when I was eight years old, and I still wasn’t afraid of needles. If any of these high school seniors can’t be as brave as an eight year old boy, their blood’s probably pretty weak anyway.”

Let me just say that I usually don’t play macho games or talk smack. But I spoke in terms of a challenge, and I got applauded for it. People got excited, especially the young men. When the time came, we marched out to the gym and stood in line. At that point I hadn’t been stuck with a needle in years. It’s very different when you’re used to it. But I couldn’t remember the last time my stoicism had been tested, and my memories of the many needles had become cloudy and I found it difficult to steel myself against a pain that I could only vaguely imagine.

I started to panic, but I kept it in check. I remained natural, though I rolled up my sleeves and started poking hard at my viens with my fingernail, trying to remember the sensation and how cavalier I used to be about it.

When my turn came I sat down and the man started asking questions, filling out his paperwork. When I told him my medical history, he pulled the form off the clipboard and dropped it in the wastebasket. They couldn’t take my blood. “Next!”

sometimes after i give blood i feel a tiny bit light-headed.

but that’s about the worst of it, and it passes pretty quickly.

it’s the least amount of effort a person can make and still make an important contribution to save someone’s life.

and in all honesty, NO, it’s not the most fun thing to do in the world. but, it is the right thing to do

if you have had problems donating in the past, there is no reason to feel guilty about not doing it anymore.

but if the worst of it is a little sting in the arm and an hour lost from your day…
SHAME… boo hiss


I’m pink therefore I’m Spam

i’ve donated blood a few times and have never had a problem with the actual ‘donating of the blood’, it’s getting my blood pressure taken that freaks me out. yech.

but what can i say, i’m a trooper. :smiley:


“If anybody wants a sheep, that is proof that he exists.”

I get called all the time to donate blood. I’ve never had any problems but the last time I was there, the lady sitting next to me passed out.

Did they make you make a fist over and over? One time I gave blood I felt a little queasy for a bit. I figured out that I was making too tight a fist and after I relaxed a little the feeling went away. Whenever I finish, I sit down and have a glass of juice and a cookie before I leave.

I only donated once. Two friends of mine had just been in a car accident. One died, the other used up so much blood that his father asked his friends to donate in his name. So I did. Having always been a complete scaredy-cat of needles, I was surprised by how traumatic it wasn’t, but then I was pretty numb at the time anyway.

Now, I’m not allowed to give blood, because of this stupid mad cow disease rule.

I’ve only given blood once, I feel like I should probably do it more. The odd thing was that my experience was the complete opposite of everyone else’s–nothing negative at all. People were telling me I’d be tired and sleep really well that night. Actually, that evening I felt like I was full of energy, and when I went to bed I was all restless; it took me hours to get to sleep. I felt like I could’ve gone out and climbed a mountain if I’d wanted to.

The only thing I can figure is my body was on kind of a “high” from feeling like I’d done a good deed for the day, I don’t know.

I’ve only given blood once and that experience was very comparable to Cabbage’s. However, when I was in a hospital for a week because of a clot in my leg, I had to get blood drawn every six hours or so for about five days. My experiences showed that it all depends on the person taking the blood (phlebotamist{sp?}). Some of those people are just sloppy. One night a guy came in when I was half asleep. Suddenly I was fully awake because of the huge amount of pain. That guy just wasn’t very good at drawing blood. The next day a new phlebotamist came and I told him about the other guy the night before. He said he’d do better, and he did. It was totally painless. Simply put: He had skills, the other guy didn’t.

I have type O+ and have donated a number of times, my only gripe is, they never listen to me. I’m a ‘fast’ bleeder, I always tell them this, but it never fails that they stick me and blood shoots out over walls, all over my clothes, and sometimes the person who stuck me in the first place. So I still give, but I wish I could find some plastic clothes to wear.


“Consider it a challenge…”

I donate every two months. My K of C council sponsors two blood drives every year, and I do the others at work – the Pentagon has the Red Cross out here three times per week.

I am always in favor of donating right up until the time that I’m on the table, they’ve swabbed my arm, and are ready to stick the needle in. Then I always get the feeling that this is a really bad idea, and I should be there. But of course it’s too late to back out then! So I grit my teeth, look away, and think of England.

By the time the two month wait is over, I never remember that feeling, and so in I go again!

Notes from the front: a good phlebotomist (sp?) makes all the difference in the world. The clumsy folks (thankfully few and far between) really irk me, fumbling around trying to find and hit a vein like they went to the Larry, Moe, & Curly School of Needles. The good ones just thump you, find a vein, and it’s like Jed Clampett’s land after he shot at some food.

Anyway – donate! It is a great act of charity.

  • Rick

I donate blood on a regular basis. I just warn the nurses that my veins are difficult to find and that I’m a sloooooooow bleeder. I sometimes get a bruise but otherwise it’s fine. A nurse once told me that if every person in Canada who can give blood did so twice a year, there wouldn’t be a shortage of blood. Kinda blew my mind.


Eat right, exercise daily, live clean, die anyway.

I’ve donated about 3 gallons (24 times) in my life. The only problem I ever had was when I went to softball practice the day after donating. The following day, I had a huge bruise on my left forearm, from my elbow to my wrist. Didn’t hurt, but it freaked me out. The clinician said it was nothing to worry about, and that warm compresses would help break down the blood that had leaked out.

I prefer Inova Fairfax Donation Centers to any Red Cross donations. Inova has contour seats, a great selection of refreshments for after your donation, and very personable techs. Red Cross has flat gurneys and are a bit cold personally.

Being O- makes me popular on their callback lists. Sometimes they’ll call me back 4 weeks before I can donate again just to get me to make an appointment.


Wrong thinking is punished, right thinking is just as swiftly rewarded. You’ll find it an effective combination.

I’ve donated blood once. (Cut me some slack–I haven’t been old enough to donate for very long.) I was willing, not scared of needles, and didn’t have a problem until they pulled out the needle, taped me up, and I tried to sit up. I felt a little dizzy. The nurse asked, “Are you okay?” I said, “Yeah, I’m fine…no, no, I’m not.” So I lay back down. I tried to sit up a few times over the course of two hours, all unsuccessfully. They took my blood pressure again, and the nurse didn’t want to tell me what it was. I had to ask her three times before she’d tell me. Apparently my blood pressure dropped to 70/40 (from 100/60 when I came in). I think she thought it’d scare me if I knew. She didn’t know that I was thinking, “Wow, I’ve never been this close to fainting. This is kinda cool.” :wink:

After a few hours and a can of soda, I was better. A little lightheaded, but fine. And within a week, my BP was back to normal.

And I wasn’t scared of needles, but I was a little surprised by the needle they used–it’s a tube with a beveled end that they insert. It looks kinda big, especially if you were expecting a needle like the type they use for shots. But it didn’t hurt as much as I was afraid it would. That needle is intimidating, but it’s really not that bad.


Have you ever tried to tie a cherry stem in a knot with your tongue?

I’ve given blood long enough that I’ve lost count of how many times; probably around 70, I’d guess. And since they’ll give us time off to give when they come around every 8 weeks at the beautiful Suitland Federal Center where I work, it’s real easy, these days. And I’m O-, which as AWB pointed out, is real popular, being both fairly rare and universal-donor type, so I try to give frequently.

For me, the important thing is, never see that needle in your arm. I ask them to warn me before they stick it in, so I can look away. And I keep looking away until they put something over where the needle is stuck in. The couple times I saw it in there, I didn’t faint, but I sure felt queasy.

Incognito, I don’t know if this helps or not. Ruffian, I agree with the nurses - if I were you, I wouldn’t ever try to give again.

This isn’t really a bad experience…

Where I was living in Florida, the local blood bank (I guess that’s what you’d call it) was needing platelets. There was a shortage on platelets. You can donate platelets every 72 hours, whereas you can only donate blood every 2 months. So I was game, I figured, anything to help.

When you donate platelets, (I hope I’m spelling that right) they put a needle in each arm. One tube goes to a machine that extracts the platelets, and the other arm gets the blood back. Some people have said to me that that sounds dangerous. Oh well…

The machine is supposed to keep the blood at the right temperature, but if you know anything about science (or have common sense,) you’ll know that pushing a liquid thru a narrow 4-6ft tube will cause the temperature to cool significantly.

Luckily it was summer in Florida. I was wearing shorts and a t-shirt, and needed blankets before the 2hr process was done.
They let me leave and I absorb the warmth outside. I had left my windows up in my truck, and it was very hot in there. I just sat there for a few moments to warm myself back up. It felt really good to be sitting in a 110+ degree vehicle with the windows rolled up.

I’ve not given platelets again since. Not because of the experience, but because I’ve been pierced, and you can’t donate for a year. I tried. Then after my ears were ok, I had my nipples done… so I didn’t even bother going… but now, I think I’ll do it again.


“Rolling with the dopes you know. Rolling with the wrong gun on you”
“I dream that she aims to be the bloom upon my misery”

  • I Miss The Girl Soul Coughing