[QUOTE=msmith537]
[snip]
-Bill, Kill Bill Vol 2
[/QUOTE]
Bill was, however, speaking nonsense. It’s unsupported by any any version of the character. It’s Bill’s own perception of the world put on the Last Son of Krypton’s already overburdened back.
Firstly ‘born Superman’:
Superman was born Kal-El, son of Jor-El. Had Krypton not exploded he would, no doubt, have followed his father as a distinguished scientist, unless, as one story posited, he eventually got chosen to become a Green Lantern. Even the early versions of the character where Kryptonians have superpowers even on Krypton - he’d just be one of the crowd. Perhaps not even one of the great ones.
But, that wasn’t to be, so Kal was sent to Earth where the potential for him to become a superhero existed. Where he would be something other than he would have been on Krypton.
Where, also, he would be raised by the Kents. Who, both in life and death, were every bit as influential on Superman as Jor-El and Lara were. At least. Particularly in the Post-Crisis version, where, were he influenced by his Kryptonian heretage, a hero is the last thing he’d be.
They raised him from infancy to adulthood. They made him the man he became - the hero he became. ‘Clark Kent’ might be a disguise, but John and Martha/Mary Kent made Superman who he is.
Second, the ‘critique on humanity’:
The Silver Age Public Clark Kent - the klutz, the weakling, the nobody - was created in adulthood. As a teenager, Clark held back his powers, so as to not get caught, but he was incredibly average. He worked in the Kents’ general store, did OK, but not outstanding in school, did well enough in gym to pass, but not standout… He was all-around average.
As an adult, he adapted a more exagerated ‘ultimate nebbish’ persona. This served two purposes: First, Superman was getting more publicity than Superboy did, so further distancing Superman and Clark helped make his identity more secure. Second, it made it easy for him to slip off to be Superman - giving someone a stomach cramp with heat vision, so his faking a worse one of his own would be believable; pretending to be claustrophobic so he could leave a space station as Clark and come back as Superman, that sort of thing.
These two things should make it obvious that ‘Super-wimp’ Clark couldn’t be a critique on humanity, couldn’t be how he sees us. Too much of making the disguise work was based around his being so much less hardy than those around him, and he’s had his whole life seeing what we’re really like, and spent his entire adolescence successfully imitating an unremarkable example of humanity.
Also, this only applies to the Silver Age version at all. The Golden Age, late Pre-Crisis, and Post-Crisis versions all play Clark as entirely average - or even a bit of a stand-out in a good way. And the modern version is definitely the son of John and Martha Kent in all the ways that matter.
(BTW, just to cover a point that hasn’t been addressed: there was a brief period in the mid-nineties where Clark WASN’T superpowered. This was the ‘Electric Supermen’/‘Superman Blue/Red’ era, where he’d transform into an energy being (well…two energy beings) and back again.)