I love movies where the main character is burned out, or beaten down, or maybe even a bad person, but then that character finds some avenue for redemption in the course of the film. The film usually (but not always) ends on a hopeful note. Let’s compile a list of such movies, shall we?
I’ll start with The Verdict. Paul Newman is a beaten-down, burned-out lawyer. A good case falls into his lap, and he nearly blows it, only to redeem himself at the end in a classic David-vs-Goliath battle against the powerful and corrupt. His closing argument is a great cinematic moment.
(I left out one subcategory - films where the main character has been through a horribly traumatic event, but then rebuilds his or her life and finds redemption.)
I go with drillrod’s pessimistic reading of Unforgiven: for me, William Munny is beyond redemption. But then, how many people do get it? Does Travis Bickle achieve redemption through his actions? Surely not. And what about The Wild Bunch? Do they get redemption or are they simply wiped out as anachronisms?
This brings me to my second point. I think that Michael Sullivan (Road to Perdition) does get his redemption. But where does the idea that the character has to die to achieve it come from? Certainly it is the very antithesis of the Christian idea, where the Redeemer’s self-sacrifice is supposed to save us all. What is the basis for the idea that death is necessary?
So perhaps the model for a Christian redemption genre is Jules in Pulp Fiction: converted by a miracle, and one of the few “bad guys” who survive the film.
Monster’s Ball was a great movie about redemption. I loved the ending because I really, really thought their relationship was doomed, and at least 3 times during the movie I thought the film was leading up to a break up based on miscommunication and lack of faith, but Hank and Leticia managed to get through it. Some people thought it was corny or unrealistic, but I thought it was great.
Jerry Maguire: He doesn’t just just go through a professional redemption (losing all of his clients but one) but he also learns to not be a cold bastard through the love of a woman (and her son). Awww.
I love that movie though. I may have to watch it again.