Not to hijack Dante G’s thread anymore than I have, I was wondering…
The bass and drums are the theme of a song in most cases. Stand in the shadows and give the band their due. I know it doesn’t seem fair in most bar-bands. Everyone wants to be a star.
Lotsa awesome rhythm sections around, to name a few:
(aside - at a Firehose gig Hurley and I exchanged shirts - I got his Big Black tee, and he got my yellow and white “My First Bells” tee.)
indeed
(if you’d grown up in his hood, Scabpicker, hopefully you wouldn’t have tried to sound like him, like too many bassists around here tried, unsuccessfully)
Bruford/Squire
aaaa heck Lee/Peart
Fripp/Wetton (King Crimson)
Rey Washam/David Wm. Sims (Rapeman)
scads of metal mentions
Hard for me to argue with this sentiment; Watt/Hurley definitely had the biggest impact on my own approach to rock of any bass/drum combo. Though with them making up 2/3 of a trio–and Mike Watt being practically a co-frontman in both bands–they do go way beyond the traditional backline duties. Shouldn’t discount them from the conversation in any way as far as I’m concerned–nor Entwistle/Moon, who have a similar dynamic within the Who–but it’s a very different concept than having the bass and drums working in tandem to lock in the groove and drive the song. And of course, Watt/Hurley and Entwistle/Moon could both do that effectively too–it just wasn’t required of them as much in the context of their music.
My favorites not yet mentioned, all of which are more on the backline-groove, song-driving-battery tip:
Bruce Thomas/Pete Thomas (Elvis Costello and the Attractions)
Duck Dunn/Al Jackson Jr (Booker T and the MGs/Stax Records House Band)
Aston “Family Man” Barrett/Carlton Barrett (The Wailers)
Tina Weymouth/Chris Frantz (Talking Heads)
[ul]
[li] Dave Weckl and John Pattitucci[/li]Steve Gadd and Anthony Jackson
AL Foster and Marcus Miller
Lenny White and Stanley Clarke
Kermit Driscoll and Joey Baron
Phil Collins and Mike Rutcherford
Scott LaFaro and Paul Motian
[/ul]
Good enough for now.
This would never qualify as “greatest” but is a favorite of mine: When listening to the isolated instrumental track of She Loves You, I’m always impressed by how tight Ringo and Paul were.